Educause Security Discussion mailing list archives
Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans
From: "Consolvo, Corbett D" <cc72 () TXSTATE EDU>
Date: Thu, 10 Apr 2008 08:33:10 -0500
In my experience, as much as I hate full scans (and the challenges they bring), they have caught things that the on-access scanner has not. Thanks, Corbett Consolvo Texas State University From: The EDUCAUSE Security Constituent Group Listserv [mailto:SECURITY () LISTSERV EDUCAUSE EDU] On Behalf Of Jenkins, Matthew Sent: Thursday, April 10, 2008 8:13 AM To: SECURITY () LISTSERV EDUCAUSE EDU Subject: Re: [SECURITY] AV - Full scans or On Access Scans In theory, the on-access scanner would nab the malware if the malware tried to execute after signatures to detect it were installed. Hence, a full system scan shouldn't be necessary, because the on-access scanner should detect all malware/virus/Trojan/malicious code before it executes. Most on-access scanners scan things as they are read/wrote from/to the file system, so even if someone tried to copy a virus it should be caught. We see this a lot on our FTP server where students will upload infected Word documents and the on-access scanner will immediately quarantine the file. If the AV engine is shutdown or the signatures are out of date due to a Trojan-type piece of code, the enterprise console or a NAC should catch this and report back. This would catch any attacks where either the code was executed during a time when no signatures were available to catch it or the on-access scanner was disabled for administrative purposes (i.e. software installation). If the on-access scanner was not compromised and the signatures were updated after the malicious piece of code was installed, the AV software should catch the malware in memory with a 'quick scan'. However, because that's all theory, I don't trust on-access scans enough to not do (or want to do) a full system scan of all hosts. I am curious if anyone else has thoughts on that. Does a full system scan really buy us anything, other than sleep at night (a highly valued commodity)? Just a thought. Matt Matthew Jenkins Network/Server Administrator Fairmont State University Visit us online at www.fairmontstate.edu<http://www.fairmontstate.edu/> From: The EDUCAUSE Security Constituent Group Listserv [mailto:SECURITY () LISTSERV EDUCAUSE EDU] On Behalf Of Charlie Prothero Sent: Wednesday, April 09, 2008 9:13 PM To: SECURITY () LISTSERV EDUCAUSE EDU Subject: Re: [SECURITY] AV - Full scans or On Access Scans We had the same problem at Keystone College. Theoretical question here: Say a piece of malware gets onto a machine before your AV software has a signature for it. The AV software is subsequently updated to detect that malware. If the malware had managed to install itself, it's gone on the next reboot. Otherwise, it's just sitting on the drive, undetected because it isn't referenced. If it was, the AV software would nab it. Obviously, it's not *desirable* to be storing a virus collection, but how much of a problem would it be, provided the AV on-access scanner is active?
Current thread:
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans, (continued)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Ken De Cruyenaere (Apr 09)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans I. W. Woodle (Apr 09)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Mike Hanson (Apr 09)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Jenkins, Matthew (Apr 09)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Basgen, Brian (Apr 09)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Charlie Prothero (Apr 09)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Halliday,Paul (Apr 09)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Eric Case (Apr 09)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Jenkins, Matthew (Apr 10)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Jenkins, Matthew (Apr 10)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Consolvo, Corbett D (Apr 10)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Zach Jansen (Apr 10)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Marc Scarborough (Apr 10)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Jenkins, Matthew (Apr 10)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Eric Case (Apr 10)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Basgen, Brian (Apr 10)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Valdis Kletnieks (Apr 10)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Di Fabio, Andrea (Apr 10)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Gary Flynn (Apr 10)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Halliday,Paul (Apr 10)
- Re: AV - Full scans or On Access Scans Jimmy Kuo (Apr 10)
(Thread continues...)