Educause Security Discussion mailing list archives
Re: Microsoft antivirus
From: Jeff Kell <jeff-kell () UTC EDU>
Date: Mon, 11 Mar 2013 19:24:54 -0400
On 3/11/2013 7:06 PM, Jason Gates wrote:
I've used FEP with SCCM and enjoy the management and reporting abilities of FEP but i'm concerned about the quality of malware protection. Through reading, testing and real world experiences with the antivirus product i've found that its malware protection is left wanting. In test cases FEP did not remove/detect all the malware, leaving malware parts still installed and functioning.
Sure, it misses stuff. But they all do. We've gone from Symantec to McAfee to Forefront and there really isn't that much of a delta in terms of protection. With current zero-day "click here to infect your computer" drive-bys, nobody is going to keep you clean, but it should look like they're making an effort. In the "big picture" of things, Forefront was much less "high-maintenance" and "obnoxiously fat footprint" that the predecessors. Having updates integrated (more or less) into windows updates is a plus. I still have nighmares about EPO :) I've considered application white-listing, but not sure how many monkey wrenches that throws into the works. And how much of that is Active Directory dependent. There's no magic bullet. For no more return that you should expect from an A/V these days, FF was priced right on campus agreement. We even drank the FOPE Kool-Aid for our Exchange filtering... Jeff
Current thread:
- Re: Microsoft antivirus, (continued)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Drew Perry (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Dexter Caldwell (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Drew Perry (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus David Opitz (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Jim Stasik (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Rick Baker (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Fisher, Matthew C (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Ed Zawacki (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Tim Doty (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Santabarbara, Angelo (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Jason Gates (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Jeff Kell (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Barros, Jacob (Mar 12)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Jason Gates (Mar 12)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Tim Doty (Mar 12)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Ed Zawacki (Mar 11)
- Re: Microsoft antivirus Santabarbara, Angelo (Mar 11)