nanog mailing list archives
Re: The Cidr Report
From: "Stephen J. Wilcox" <steve () telecomplete co uk>
Date: Sun, 13 Feb 2005 19:32:49 +0000 (GMT)
On Mon, 14 Feb 2005, Warren Kumari, Ph.D, CCIE# 9190 wrote:
On Feb 13, 2005, at 2:31 AM, Christopher L. Morrow wrote:There are multiple reasons for deaggregation aside from 'dumb operator', some are even 'valid' if you look at them from the protection standpoint.That and the "I have 1 circuit to $good_provider and 1 circuit to $bad_provider and the only way I can make them balance is to split my space in half and announce more specifics out through each provider" argument. I have also often seen people do this without announcing the aggregate because <some undefined bad thing> will happen, usually justified with much hand-waving. The people who do this can usually not be reasoned with....
this just reinforces the argument that they are lacking in technical savvy. i have a transit provider who i dont want to carry much traffic and i dont want to prepend my announcements.. by looking at that providers supported customer communities i just get them to prepend as they export to other major networks thus moving the main volume of the traffic to the desired ingress paths no deaggregation, no prepending.. Steve
Current thread:
- Re: The Cidr Report, (continued)
- Re: The Cidr Report Hank Nussbacher (Feb 12)
- Re: The Cidr Report Alexander Koch (Feb 12)
- Re: The Cidr Report Fredy Kuenzler (Feb 12)
- Re: The Cidr Report Vinny Abello (Feb 12)
- Re: The Cidr Report Christopher L. Morrow (Feb 12)
- Re: The Cidr Report Alexander Koch (Feb 13)
- Re: The Cidr Report Christopher L. Morrow (Feb 13)
- RE: The Cidr Report Justin Ryburn (Feb 13)
- RE: The Cidr Report Stephen J. Wilcox (Feb 13)
- Re: The Cidr Report Warren Kumari, Ph.D, CCIE# 9190 (Feb 13)
- Re: The Cidr Report Stephen J. Wilcox (Feb 13)
- Re: The Cidr Report Michael Smith (Feb 13)
- Re: The Cidr Report Christopher L. Morrow (Feb 13)
- Re: The Cidr Report Warren Kumari, Ph.D, CCIE# 9190 (Feb 13)
- Re: The Cidr Report Stephen J. Wilcox (Feb 13)
- Re: The Cidr Report Philip Smith (Feb 12)
- Re: The Cidr Report Jerry Pasker (Feb 12)
- Re: The Cidr Report Aaron Hopkins (Feb 13)
- Re: The Cidr Report Patrick W Gilmore (Feb 13)
- Re: The Cidr Report Mark Prior (Feb 14)
- Re: The Cidr Report Marc Binderberger (Feb 11)