nanog mailing list archives
Re: Port scanning legal
From: "Majdi S. Abbas" <msa () samurai sfo dead-dog com>
Date: Tue, 19 Dec 2000 19:28:51 -0800
On Tue, Dec 19, 2000 at 06:46:32PM -0800, L. Sassaman wrote:
I have tcpwrappers set to trigger a portscan after certain actions... and I have inadvertently scanned a section of the navy.mil network because of this. (They're running raptor... what a surprise.) I was not approached by any men in black after this happened. I suspect the US Military is well accustomed to having its networks scanned.
Speaking for myself, I was doing a routine sweep of one of my (now former) employer's netblocks, and typoed one of the quads in a /19 -- inadvertantly nmapping a navy.mil block, which I did not realize until I looked at the output file created. I made a note of it, expecting at the very least an email about it. Nothing at all happened. As Len has noted, this is a fairly common occurance for anyone on the internet, particularly the US military, and is not going to raise many eyebrows. I think a good part of the reason that portscanning remains legal is situations like these -- it is very hard (or involves a large amount of alcohol) to try and open someone else's car or home door. It is not very hard to inadvertantly nmap or ping the wrong address. Given that, can we please stop bickering over it? --msa
Current thread:
- Re: Port scanning legal, (continued)
- Re: Port scanning legal mdevney (Dec 19)
- Re: Port scanning legal Christian Kuhtz (Dec 19)
- Re: Port scanning legal Todd Suiter (Dec 19)
- Re: Port scanning legal Stephen Sprunk (Dec 19)
- RE: Port scanning legal Matthew S. Hallacy (Dec 20)
- RE: Port scanning legal Mark Borchers (Dec 19)
- RE: Port scanning legal Roeland Meyer (Dec 19)
- Re: Port scanning legal Shawn McMahon (Dec 19)
- Re: Port scanning legal Dan Hollis (Dec 19)
- Re: Port scanning legal L. Sassaman (Dec 19)
- Re: Port scanning legal Majdi S. Abbas (Dec 19)
- Re: Port scanning legal Shawn McMahon (Dec 19)
- RE: Port scanning legal Dan Hollis (Dec 19)
- RE: Port scanning legal Steven J. Sobol (Dec 19)
- RE: Port scanning legal Patrick Evans (Dec 19)
- Re: Port scanning legal Andrew Brown (Dec 20)
- Re: Port scanning legal Shawn McMahon (Dec 19)