nanog mailing list archives
Re: BBN Peering issues
From: shields () crosslink net (Michael Shields)
Date: Sun, 16 Aug 1998 20:28:09 +0000 (GMT)
Well that's all fine and dandy. however the internet has worked for 20 years that I have been asssociated with it, on the working principal that no one hassled or encumbered peering charges and there were no board rooms or stockholders and that is why it worked, because people knew what they were doing.
The reason it's worked is that connecting network A to network B generally provides value to both, so we've had a multi-decade connectfest. Value of connecting exceeded cost of connecting. Lately we are seeing shadings between the traditional "customer/peer" dichotomy. Traditionally peers treated each other as true equals because the cost of determining the relative value to A of connecting to B and to B of connecting to A in order to determine who should pay whom, including badwill cost, exceeded the expected payment. BBN thinks is no longer the case and if you are going to convince them otherwise, you'll have to convince them that it is in *their* best interest to continue free peering with Exodus, not that it is in "the Internet's" best interest. As Karl says, an effective way to do that is to cancel your BBN contract. In fact this is almost certainly the only effective way to convince them. If you're not a BBN customer there is no reason they should listen to you. -- Shields, CrossLink.
Current thread:
- Re: BBN Peering issues, (continued)
- Re: BBN Peering issues steve (Aug 14)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Sean M. Doran (Aug 14)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Matt Sommer (Aug 14)
- FW: BBN Peering issues Lawrence A. Deleski (Aug 14)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Sean Donelan (Aug 14)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Hank Nussbacher (Aug 15)
- RE: BBN Peering issues Goldstein_William (Aug 16)
- RE: BBN Peering issues Goldstein_William (Aug 16)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Karl Denninger (Aug 16)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Henry Linneweh (Aug 16)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Michael Shields (Aug 16)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Mark Tripod (Aug 17)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Michael Shields (Aug 16)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Tracy J. Snell (Aug 17)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Vadim Antonov (Aug 18)