nanog mailing list archives
Re: Using private APNIC range in US
From: Fred Baker <fred () cisco com>
Date: Thu, 18 Mar 2010 09:34:47 -0700
Are they using them only within their domain(s), and ARIN addresses outside, or are they advertising them to their upstream(s) to be readvertised into the backbone? If they are using them internally and NAT'ing to the outside, they're not hurting themselves or anyone else. I would personally let them alone. If they are advertising them outside, it adds a small prefix in the ARIN domain that doesn't get aggregated by the upstream. Among 300K such prefixes it is probably noise, but gently suggesting that they use something aggregatable into their upstream's allocation would help a little bit in that regard. What they are most likely hurting is themselves, really; a datagram sent to the address from an ISP outside themselves probably travels via Australia or an Australian ISP. On Mar 18, 2010, at 8:52 AM, Jaren Angerbauer wrote:
Hi all, I have a client here in the US, that I just discovered is using a host of private IPs that (as I understand) belong to APNIC (i.e. 1.7.154.70, 1.7.154.00-99, etc.) for their web servers. I'm assuming that the addresses probably nat to a [US] public IP. I'm not familiar enough with the use of private address space outside of ARIN (i.e. 192.0.0.0, 10.0.0.0, etc) but I figure if their sites are up and accessible it must be working for them. I'm just wondering if there is any recommendation or practice around this -- using private IP ranges from another country. Thanks. --Jaren
http://www.ipinc.net/IPv4.GIF
Current thread:
- Using private APNIC range in US Jaren Angerbauer (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Michael Holstein (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Owen DeLong (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Jaren Angerbauer (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Larry Sheldon (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Tom Ammon (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Mark Smith (Mar 21)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Joel Jaeggli (Mar 21)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Jaren Angerbauer (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Jonathan Lassoff (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Cian Brennan (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Owen DeLong (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Jared Mauch (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US William Allen Simpson (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Larry Sheldon (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Matt Shadbolt (Mar 18)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Charles Mills (Mar 19)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Craig Vuljanic (Mar 19)
- RE: Using private APNIC range in US Eric J Esslinger (Mar 19)
- Re: Using private APNIC range in US Graham Beneke (Mar 20)