Re: DNS pulling BGP routes?

[Masataka Ohta <mohta () necom830 hpcl titech ac jp>]

Tom Beecher wrote:

> > For network neutrality, backbone providers *MUST* be neutral
> > for contents they carry.
> >
> > However, CDN providers having their own backbone are using
> > their backbone for contents they prefer, which is *NOT*
> > neutral at all.
> >
> > As such, access/retail providers may pay for peering with
> > neutral backbone providers for their customers but should
> > reject direct peering request from, actively behaving against
> > neutrality, CDN providers.

> If I am understanding you correctly, are you arguing that anyone with a
> network MUST be forced to become a transit provider for anyone else, in the
> name of "neutrality"?

No, not at all.

For example, CDN (N stands for a network) operators may rely on
neutral transit providers to connect their CDN to access/retail
providers.

But, I certainly mean that CDN operators should not request
peering directly to access/retail ISPs merely because they have
their own transit, because the transit is not at all neutral.

                                        Masataka Ohta