nanog mailing list archives
Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB)
From: Danny McPherson <danny () tcb net>
Date: Sat, 25 Oct 2014 09:23:45 -0600
On 2014-10-25 06:57, Sandra Murphy wrote:
Other RIR based RIRs have the same ability to protect prefixes in their realm of control. (See RFC 2725 RPSS)(*) (I think that APNIC is doing pretty much as RIPE is.) Even RIPE is not secure for prefixes outside their region. (There's one maintainer that anyone can use to register anything for resources outside the region - password publicly available, etc.) Non-RIR based IRRs do not have the ability to tie the register-er toauthority for the resource, so they have no base on which to build theRIPE sort of security.
Those are fair points Sandy, I agree they need to be resolved.It's just that RPKI feels like a _really heavy solution to _that problem. That said, if that problem were solved nearly all of what I care about with regard to routing security (and inter-domain anti-spoofing) could be addressed.
-danny
Current thread:
- Re: RADB, (continued)
- Re: RADB Brandon Wade (Oct 08)
- Re: RADB joel jaeggli (Oct 08)
- Re: RADB Charles Gucker (Oct 08)
- ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Danny McPherson (Oct 23)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Christopher Morrow (Oct 23)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Danny McPherson (Oct 23)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) John Sweeting (Oct 24)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Christopher Morrow (Oct 24)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Baldur Norddahl (Oct 24)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Sandra Murphy (Oct 25)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Danny McPherson (Oct 25)
- Re: RADB Brandon Wade (Oct 08)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Danny McPherson (Oct 25)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Bill Woodcock (Oct 25)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) John Curran (Oct 25)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Danny McPherson (Oct 25)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Randy Bush (Oct 25)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Ca By (Oct 25)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) John Curran (Oct 25)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Randy Bush (Oct 26)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) John Curran (Oct 26)
- Re: ARIN / RIR Pragmatism (WAS: Re: RADB) Dmitry Burkov (Oct 26)