nanog mailing list archives
Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth
From: Jeroen Massar <jeroen () unfix org>
Date: Sun, 26 Sep 2010 00:01:38 +0200
On 2010-09-25 23:53, Valdis.Kletnieks () vt edu wrote:
On Sat, 25 Sep 2010 21:43:25 BST, Matthew Walster said:Was anything ever standardised in that field? I imagine with much of P2P traffic being (how shall I put this...) less than legal, it's of questionable legality and the ISPs would not want to be held liable for the content cached there?The ISP is off the hook on that one. 17 USC 512(2) specifically carves out an ISP safe-harbor for data that's only cached on an ISP's servers due to an end user's request. IANAL, so have somebody you pay for legal advice read 17 USC 512(2) and tell you what they think.
So it that is true, if you define "news server" as a "cache", even though you have to buy several terabytes, make that several petabytes, to "be able to "cache" this data one along with all the network environment to support getting data out of this "cache", the ISP is completely in the clear even though that "cache" is the sole single point where one can retrieve that "cached" data from even years after the data was originally put on the network, the original is gone and that "cache" works without anything being attached to it ? :) Oh, one just have to love these things called laws... good that they are protecting the right parts of the distribution network eh ;) Greets, Jeroen
Current thread:
- Online games stealing your bandwidth Rodrick Brown (Sep 25)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Matthew Walster (Sep 25)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Valdis . Kletnieks (Sep 25)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Jeroen Massar (Sep 25)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Jeffrey S. Young (Sep 25)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Adrian Chadd (Sep 25)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Matthew Walster (Sep 25)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Bill Stewart (Sep 28)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Franck Martin (Sep 28)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Valdis . Kletnieks (Sep 25)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth gordon b slater (Sep 26)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Jack Bates (Sep 27)
- RE: Online games stealing your bandwidth Leigh Porter (Sep 27)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Valdis . Kletnieks (Sep 27)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Matthew Walster (Sep 25)
- Re: Online games stealing your bandwidth Richard Barnes (Sep 27)