nanog mailing list archives
Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic
From: Tim Salo <salo () networkcs com>
Date: Tue, 26 May 1998 22:41:09 -0500 (CDT)
Date: Fri, 22 May 1998 22:02:47 -0500 (CDT) From: Tim Salo <salo () networkcs com> To: nanog () merit edu Subject: Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic [...] I believe that all four of the winning NSFNET NAP submissions proposed nationwide "NAPs". I believe that the reason they didn't happen is that the NSF asked for and assumed it would get four geographically-focused solutions. I suspect that the notion of awarding four NAPs, all of which covered all of the country, provided the NSF a certain amount of heartburn. I believe that the nationwide NAP concept died, (or was killed), at the time for administrative, not technical, reasons. But, this is all speculation on my part... [...]
A presumably well informed observer sent me private e-mail that questioned my account. I read only one of the winning NAP proposals, the one I worked on. My speculation that all of the winning proposals talked about nationwide NAPs was based on conversations after the fact, including with authors of competing proposals. So, I believe that all of those who submitted winning NAP proposals were thinking about nationwide NAPs, but some may not have, based on the e-mail I received, included those thoughts in their proposals. At any rate, my thesis is that the concept of a nationwide layer-two solution has been around for several years, at least since the time that the NAP proposals were written. I might add, however, that we are collectively still learning about how best to make use of these very large layer-two services. -tjs
Current thread:
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic, (continued)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Alan Hannan (May 26)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Sean M. Doran (May 22)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Tim Salo (May 22)
- Message not available
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Jay R. Ashworth (May 23)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Tom Perrine (May 26)
- Message not available
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Sean Donelan (May 26)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Damian O'Gorman (May 26)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic dirk (May 26)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Greg A. Woods (May 26)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic D'Arcy J.M. Cain (May 27)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Damian O'Gorman (May 26)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Tim Salo (May 26)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Bob Aiken (May 27)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Michael Gibson (May 27)
- Re: different thinking on exchanging traffic Damian O'Gorman (May 27)