Firewall Wizards mailing list archives
Re: Firewall bake-off?
From: "K K" <kkadow () gmail com>
Date: Mon, 19 Mar 2007 15:27:45 -0500
On 3/19/07, Marcus J. Ranum <mjr () ranum com> wrote:
K K wrote:Any organization deploying firewalls needs to know their own comfort level and requirements, and choose the solution which is right for them.joel l huebner wrote:My vote would be SecureComputing's Sidewinder product line... Very SECURE, very easy to use!But not exactly know as speed demons, and no published 64-byte PPS throughput benchmarks.
I should have put an emoticon at the end of that sentence :)
It's a proxy firewall. PPS benchmarks are irrelevant because the traffic is moving through layer 7.
If only that were the case for all TCP and UDP higher-level protocols. Many ports, when enabled, are passed with a generic proxy, not much more sophisticated than your original protocol-agnostic TCP "plug" proxy. Same goes for just about every other "proxy" or "deep inspection" product on the market -- some protocols are deep, others shallow. If you're lucky, the vendor clearly indicates which is which. And like every other vendor, the best Sidewinder benchmark results are obtained with the most "expensive" inspection features disabled, but, IIRC, they don't cheat and turn off proxying entirely.
This isn't intended as a bash at you, Kevin, because you're not the one who raised PPS as a measure of firewall performance (I think it was Carson) - but if someone starts talking about PPS as a firewall benchmark, they may as well hold up a big sign that reads: "I DO NOT UNDERSTAND WHAT A FIREWALL DOES"
Exactly. Kevin Kadow -- Moderator, unofficial Sidewinder Users group http://groups.yahoo.com/group/sidewinder-users/ _______________________________________________ firewall-wizards mailing list firewall-wizards () listserv icsalabs com https://listserv.icsalabs.com/mailman/listinfo/firewall-wizards
Current thread:
- Firewall bake-off? James Hampton (Mar 12)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? Carson Gaspar (Mar 13)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? James Hampton (Mar 14)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? joel l huebner (Mar 18)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? K K (Mar 18)
- Message not available
- Re: Firewall bake-off? Marcus J. Ranum (Mar 19)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? K K (Mar 19)
- Message not available
- Re: Firewall bake-off? Marcus J. Ranum (Mar 19)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? K K (Mar 18)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? Jim MacLeod (Mar 19)
- Message not available
- Re: Firewall bake-off? Marcus J. Ranum (Mar 19)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? Carric Dooley (Mar 22)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? Carson Gaspar (Mar 13)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? Carson Gaspar (Mar 21)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? Zachary Grafton (Mar 21)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? Jim MacLeod (Mar 21)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? Zachary Grafton (Mar 21)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? Patrick M. Hausen (Mar 21)
- Re: Firewall bake-off? K K (Mar 21)