nanog mailing list archives
RE: Jon Postel Re: 202210301538.AYC
From: Vasilenko Eduard via NANOG <nanog () nanog org>
Date: Mon, 31 Oct 2022 16:03:37 +0000
It is believed by many that 2 terms should be the maximum for one position of any chair (if it is a democracy). It is evidently not the case for IETF - people stay in power for decades. It is just a fact that is not possible to dispute. Yes, Nomcom is the mechanism for AD and above. I do not want to sort out how exactly it is performed. By the way, WG chairs have been put aside from any election mechanisms. If any politician would manage to possess power for more than 2 terms - he would be immediately called "totalitarian". Even if he would say that there is a mechanism for it. Eduard -----Original Message----- From: Donald Eastlake [mailto:d3e3e3 () gmail com] Sent: Monday, October 31, 2022 4:28 PM To: Vasilenko Eduard <vasilenko.eduard () huawei com>; North American Network Operators' Group <nanog () nanog org> Subject: Re: Jon Postel Re: 202210301538.AYC On Mon, Oct 31, 2022 at 2:37 AM Vasilenko Eduard via NANOG <nanog () nanog org> wrote:
1. What is going on on the Internet is not democracy even formally, because there is no formal voting. 3GPP, ETSI, 802.11 have voting. IETF decisions are made by bosses who did manage to gain power (primarily by establishing a proper network of relationships). It could be even called “totalitarian” because IETF bosses could stay in one position for decades.
I do not see how it can be called totalitarian given the IETF Nomcom appointment and recall mechanisms. Admittedly it is not full on Sortition (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition) but it is just one level of indirection from Sortition. (See https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbestechcouncil/2020/08/20/indirection-the-unsung-hero-of-software-engineering/?sh=2cc673587f47) Thanks, Donald
... Eduard
Current thread:
- RE: jon postel, (continued)
- RE: jon postel Adam Thompson (Oct 20)
- Re: jon postel Dave Taht (Oct 17)
- Re: jon postel Miles Fidelman (Oct 18)
- Re: jon postel michael brooks - ESC (Oct 18)
- Re: jon postel John Curran (Oct 17)
- Re: jon postel Greg Skinner via NANOG (Oct 17)
- Re: jon postel Noah (Oct 30)
- Re: Jon Postel Re: 202210301538.AYC Abraham Y. Chen (Oct 30)
- RE: Jon Postel Re: 202210301538.AYC Vasilenko Eduard via NANOG (Oct 30)
- Re: Jon Postel Re: 202210301538.AYC Donald Eastlake (Oct 31)
- RE: Jon Postel Re: 202210301538.AYC Vasilenko Eduard via NANOG (Oct 31)
- Re: Jon Postel Re: 202210301538.AYC William Allen Simpson (Oct 31)
- Re: jon postel Jay Hennigan (Oct 16)