nanog mailing list archives
Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers
From: Christopher Morrow <morrowc.lists () gmail com>
Date: Wed, 11 Dec 2019 10:16:29 -0500
On Wed, Dec 11, 2019 at 5:52 AM Rubens Kuhl <rubensk () gmail com> wrote:
Which brings me to my favorite possible RPKI-IRR integration: a ROA that says that IRR objects on IRR source x with maintainer Y are authoritative for a given number resource. Kinda like SPF for BGP.Is this required? or a crutch for use until a network can publish all of their routing data in the RPKI?It provides an adoption path based on the information already published in IRRs by operators for some years. It also covers for the fact that RPKI currently is only origin-validation.
I would think that if you(royal you) already are publishing: "these are the routes i'm going to originate (and here are my customer lists)" and you (royal you) are accepting the effort to publish 1 'new' thing in the RPKI. you could just as easily take the 'stuff I'm going to publish in IRR' and 'also publish in RPKI'. Right? So adoption path aside, because that seems like a weird argument (since your automation to make IRR data appear can ALSO just send rpki updates), your belief is that: "Hey, this irr object is really, really me" is still useful/required/necessary/interesting? -chris
Current thread:
- Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Mark Tinka (Dec 10)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Randy Bush (Dec 10)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Arturo Servin (Dec 10)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Job Snijders (Dec 10)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Rubens Kuhl (Dec 10)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Christopher Morrow (Dec 10)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Rubens Kuhl (Dec 11)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Christopher Morrow (Dec 11)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Matt Corallo (Dec 11)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Christopher Morrow (Dec 11)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Matt Corallo (Dec 11)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Arturo Servin (Dec 10)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Rubens Kuhl (Dec 11)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Christopher Morrow (Dec 11)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Randy Bush (Dec 10)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Nick Hilliard (Dec 11)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Randy Bush (Dec 16)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Mark Tinka (Dec 16)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Randy Bush (Dec 17)
- Re: Starting to Drop Invalids for Customers Mark Tinka (Dec 17)