Re: Should login pages be protected by SSL?

[Amir Herzberg <herzbea () macs biu ac il>]

Andrew van der Stock wrote:
> Depends on the value of the system in use.
...
> OTOH, where the login leads to private data, such as your name and  
> address, I feel that corporations have a duty of care to protect your  
> data under the various privacy acts around the world. The cost of a  
> certificate is much less than potential litigation, or more to the  
> point, reputation loss if someone discovers a way around it.
I agree, and indeed, my focus in on really sensitive sites esp. banks. 
So it seems we are in agreement. I think most (or all??) security 
experts really agree here, but since some of the companies object, I am 
interested to see if there are some serious defenses of the unprotected 
login practice.
> However, if it's a shopping cart type of thing, like Amazon, the  thing 
> that should be SSL is not the browsing of goods, but the  transactions, 
> particularly the credit card and address details. 
Agreed...

> The  Visa/MC PCI 
> guidelines are quite stringent on applying reasonable  controls to this 
> data. 
Well, actually, I've worked with the card people a lot but am not aware 
of a specific requirement to use SSL to protect the form sent to the 
consumer and not just to protect the CC# in transit. Do you know? If you 
 can give me some reference, I'll appreciate. I can also ask my 
contacts. I am very interested, as one of the companies which uses 
unprotected login is Amex, and in fact we had a long argument with them 
on these questions...

> In the case of Amazon 1-click, then  effectively the 1-click is 
> the thing requiring protection, so some  form of control around that is 
> also required. 
Well, it is unfortunate that the 1-click login in Amazon is unprotected, 
see http://AmirHerzberg.com/shame.html...
<skip>
--
Best regards,

Amir Herzberg

Associate Professor
Department of Computer Science
Bar Ilan University
http://AmirHerzberg.com

New: see my Hall Of Shame of Unprotected Login pages: 
http://AmirHerzberg.com/shame.html