RE: Critical New Web Application Vulnerability Alert BOB23203115

["Arian J. Evans" <arian () anachronic com>]

Let's clarify: this was a joke.

And it wasn't.

In a stateless environment are we doing user or entity authentication
with our session token? So are we going to enhance that by doing
dual-factor entity authentication? (SSL + session token...guess we
already are). So add in tri-factor (secret URL hash token)? Is our goal
only to "raise the bar". Or do we add in user-supplied authentication
of some sort? Address state/session management principles?

Lots of questions. Lots of answers. I'm responding to this publicly as
you might not be the only one I confused. And because your response
is the funniest one I've gotten. Thank you,

> -----Original Message-----
> From: 
> Sent: Monday, December 20, 2004 11:43 PM
> To: arian () anachronic com
>
> Arian,
>
> I am not sure what the point of your "Cross X Double-Free 
> Session Riding Turbo Champion Gold" advisory is.
[...]  (me neither) [...]
> Secondary your mitigation suggestions are entirely
> impractical for any production system. (ie. Having the user 
> supply information on every single page.)

Observant.
 
> Any person subscribed to the security mailing lists are 
> already following best recommended practices. So you're
> advisory is basically "yet another reason why
> you should follow best recommended practices."

What planet do you live on? Best practices my ass. But I
get your point: you got no value from my advisory. =)
 
> Furthermore I don't understand how you can critize SecureNet 
> GmbH's "Session Riding" advisory for "overzealous marketing"
> and then proceed to invite media to contact you and you're plan
> to release a press release. If "Turbo Champion Gold" isn't marketing
> jargon I don't know what is.

You busted me sir. The truth is out. I'm a media wh***. 

Now go spike your eggnog and relax.


Arian J. Evans,
Easy to Autodelete,
Uninformed Information Security Opinion at Large,
-and-
Purveyor of Anachrony
http://www.anachronic.com

(Signed pictures of me are available upon request)