nanog mailing list archives
Re: V6 still not supported
From: Masataka Ohta <mohta () necom830 hpcl titech ac jp>
Date: Tue, 22 Mar 2022 17:08:17 +0900
John Curran wrote:
IAB hideously striked back to make IPv6 something a lot worse than CLNP and XNS.
Alas, the above characterization doesn't even come close to the actual history of IPng –
That's too recent. First, as I wrote: : TUBA is TCP/UDP over CLNP (ConnectionLess Network Protocol) designed : by so infamous OSI, which is why it was denied by IETF through : democratic process even though IAB tried to deploy it. occurred, after which the history of IPng started.
- There was an open call for proposals. - We had many submissions: Nimrod, PIP, SIP, TUBA, IPAE, CATNIP (TP/IX), ... - SIP absorbed IPAE, and then PIP merged with SIP to form SIPP - Three final proposals CATNIP, TUBA, SIPP - Chicago Big-10 workshop did final review and recommended SIPP, only using 128-bit "NSAP-like" addresses
and such steps were controlled by IAB, that is, you merely support my point that: > IAB hideously striked back to make IPv6 something a lot worse than > CLNP and XNS. It should also be noted that merger is just political ceremony to pretend IPng were resulted from cooperation of many contributors only to make it bloat by incorporating all the features without technical merits. Masataka Ohta
Current thread:
- Re: V6 still not supported, (continued)
- Re: V6 still not supported Michael Thomas (Mar 18)
- Re: V6 still not supported Tom Ivar Helbekkmo via NANOG (Mar 18)
- Re: V6 still not supported Michael Thomas (Mar 18)
- Re: V6 still not supported Nathan Angelacos (Mar 18)
- Re: V6 still not supported Michael Thomas (Mar 18)
- Re: V6 still not supported surfer (Mar 18)
- Re: V6 still not supported Michael Thomas (Mar 18)
- Re: V6 still not supported Masataka Ohta (Mar 20)
- Re: V6 still not supported John Curran (Mar 21)
- Re: V6 still not supported John Curran (Mar 21)
- Re: V6 still not supported Masataka Ohta (Mar 22)
- Re: V6 still not supported John Curran (Mar 22)
- Re: V6 still not supported Randy Bush (Mar 22)
- Re: V6 still not supported Michael Thomas (Mar 22)
- Re: V6 still not supported Christopher Morrow (Mar 22)
- Re: V6 still not supported Michael Thomas (Mar 22)
- Re: V6 still not supported George Michaelson (Mar 22)
- Re: V6 still not supported Joe Maimon (Mar 22)
- Re: V6 still not supported Michael Thomas (Mar 23)
- Re: V6 still not supported Joe Maimon (Mar 23)
- Re: V6 still not supported Michael Thomas (Mar 23)