Re: Operational need for IP address space (Re: An update on the AfriNIC situation)

[John Curran <jcurran () arin net>]

On 31 Aug 2021, at 2:23 PM, Owen DeLong <owen () delong com<mailto:owen () delong com>> wrote:

Do we have parties who postulate their operational need based on entirely internal services, or services that live 
within virtual devices in a data center?   Sure…  and some of these are indeed legitimate and fulfilled per policy.  We 
also have folks who get creative and make similar requests for purposes of obtaining address blocks from ARIN – absent 
any bona fide networking need –for subsequent monetization and these reviewed, revoked, and can be referred to criminal 
fraud proceedings.

Yes, but in the ARIN region, you have also made it very clear that if needs change, ARIN will not attempt to revoke or 
reclaim space based on that change in need.

Owen -

ARIN has full authority to revoke number resources based on breach of our Registration Services Agreement (RSA) by a 
customer. We do exercise that authority with significant caution, but will do so when the situation warrants – and I 
would expect any other RIR to do the same in enforcing the particular terms of their own RSA agreement.

As I understand it, AFRINIC has initiated a rather small number of resource reviews after completion of its most recent 
database audit – one might argue that they should have initiated more/fewer/none-at-all, but one cannot logically 
assert that AFRINIC lacks the right to enforce the plain language of their RSA agreement when a review indicates that a 
breach of that agreement has occurred.

You also may not like that the AFRINIC RSA has recipients acknowledging that they are 'bestowed with an exclusive right 
of use of those number resources within the ambit of the “need” which it has justified in its application and for no 
other purpose during the currency of the present agreement’,  but please recognize that "your client” apparently liked 
that provision well enough to agree to it in order to receive the address blocks – so there’s really not much more to 
be said in this regard.

Thanks,
/John

John Curran
President and CEO
American Registry for Internet Numbers