nanog mailing list archives
Re: 5G roadblock: labor
From: Christopher Morrow <morrowc.lists () gmail com>
Date: Mon, 30 Dec 2019 17:39:23 -0500
On Mon, Dec 30, 2019 at 4:11 PM Brian J. Murrell <brian () interlinx bc ca> wrote:
On Mon, 2019-12-30 at 09:50 -0500, Shane Ronan wrote:Also, keep in mind that 10 years ago, you didn't know you would want or need 25mbits to your phone,Who needs 25mbits to their phone?
this is the wrong argument to make... or at the least it distracts from the conversation about: "Why 5g?" because everyone can come up with a reason for/against N mbps to Xthing. (I think this is sort of shane's point, actually) 4G/LTE: o started the migration/consolidation of voice/video/data to a single bearer (well, IP anyway). o moved the (ideally) IP endpoint closer to the tower base o removed some latency, jitter, intermediaries between 'End-User' and "thing on the network" 5G: o supposedly reduces latency 'more' (brings more of the IP connection and routing closer to the tower/radio?) o simplifies management? (maybe?) keeping speed out of the conversation, the footprint for MANY 5g deploymetns in the US (and elsewhere) is likely 'hundreds of feet circles', where 4G is 'miles'. (yes you can beam-form and make ovals and such...) It'd be nice to see what benefits 5g really has for carriers and consumers/users... It looks, to me, like a bunch of the 5g hype is really: "uhm, we need to sell these carriers on the G++ ... spin up the hype machine about speed!" never mind the cost to deploy, range of deployment, changes in handset/radio gear / etc... more $ to the vendors! -chris
Current thread:
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor, (continued)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Christopher Morrow (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Michael Thomas (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Shane Ronan (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Mark Tinka (Dec 30)
- RE: 5G roadblock: labor Marshall, Quincy (Dec 30)
- [OFF-TOPIC detour] Re: 5G roadblock: labor Karl Auer (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Mark Tinka (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Mike Hammett (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Brian J. Murrell (Dec 30)
- RE: 5G roadblock: labor Keith Medcalf (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Christopher Morrow (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Michael Thomas (Dec 30)
- RE: 5G roadblock: labor Keith Medcalf (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Ca By (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Christopher Morrow (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Ca By (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Brandon Martin (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Mike Hammett (Dec 30)
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Michael Thomas (Dec 30)
- Message not available
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Michael Thomas (Dec 30)
- Message not available
- Re: 5G roadblock: labor Michael Thomas (Dec 30)