nanog mailing list archives

Re: Residential VSAT experiences?


From: Rafael Possamai <rafael () gav ufsc br>
Date: Tue, 23 Jun 2015 08:37:30 -0500

Reading about SIP made it seem like latency alone is not an issue, aside
from delays which impact verbal communication as previously mentioned. What
is going to be much worse is jitter and packet loss. You can eventually get
used to a significant delay, but dropped calls and chopped sound renders
the service useless.

On Tue, Jun 23, 2015 at 3:44 AM, Tim Franklin <tim () pelican org> wrote:

Interesting that you say that about sip. We had a client that would use
it
for sip on ships all the time. It wasn't the best but it worked. Ping
times
were between 500-700ms.

It really depends on your expectations - or more to the point, your
end-users' expectations.

I've tested SIP in the lab up to 2000ms RTT.  The protocols all hang
together and keep working, but it's obviously very much in walkie-talkie
mode, you can't hold a normal duplex conversation.  500ms there's more of
the talking over each other / "sorry, you go" / "no, you go" dance, but it
*is* workable.  If your end-user is expecting land-line replacement
though...

Regards,
Tim.




Current thread: