nanog mailing list archives
Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are …."
From: Larry Sheldon <LarrySheldon () cox net>
Date: Tue, 18 Feb 2014 13:11:03 -0600
On 2/18/2014 11:20 AM, Jay Ashworth wrote:
Here's a piece which uses the MIT ANA data to assert that the job is mostly done already. Unless I'm very much mistaken, it appears that a large percentage of the failed BCP 38 spoofing tests listed in that data are actually due to customer side NAT routers dropping packets... which is of course egress filtering rather than ingress filtering, and thus doesn't actually apply to our questions. Am I interpreting that correctly?
The date seems a little past "buy by" in light of the very recent observations and comments here.
http://www.senki.org/everyone-should-be-deploying-bcp-38-wait-they-are/
-- Requiescas in pace o email Two identifying characteristics of System Administrators: Ex turpi causa non oritur actio Infallibility, and the ability to learn from their mistakes. (Adapted from Stephen Pinker)
Current thread:
- "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are …." Jay Ashworth (Feb 18)
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." Dave Bell (Feb 18)
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." Patrick W. Gilmore (Feb 18)
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." Jared Mauch (Feb 18)
- Changing the way we talk about BCP38 [Was: Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...."] Paul Ferguson (Feb 18)
- Re: Changing the way we talk about BCP38 [Was: Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...."] Dobbins, Roland (Feb 18)
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." Tony Tauber (Feb 18)
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." Dobbins, Roland (Feb 18)
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." Patrick W. Gilmore (Feb 18)
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." Dave Bell (Feb 18)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are …." Larry Sheldon (Feb 18)
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." James Milko (Feb 18)
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." Robert Drake (Feb 18)
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." Jay Ashworth (Feb 18)
- RE: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." Adam Vitkovsky (Feb 20)
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." Jay Ashworth (Feb 20)
- Re: "Everyone should be deploying BCP 38! Wait, they are ...." James Milko (Feb 18)