nanog mailing list archives
Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query)
From: Masataka Ohta <mohta () necom830 hpcl titech ac jp>
Date: Fri, 07 Sep 2012 15:50:15 +0900
Sean Harlow wrote:
None of these options are impacted by being behind a NAT as long as they have the ability to open a port via UPnP or equivalent, so if in an ideal world all client software understood SRV records this particular negative of NAT would be of minimal impact.
My point is that the impact can be minimized if 1) a set of port numbers is statically allocated to a host behind NAT without UPnP or PCP, just as allocating a static address to a host, which means there is no security concern w.r.t. dynamic assignment. Dynamic DNS update is not necessary, either. UPnP or PCP can still be used to collect information for reverse translation. 2) reverse translation can be performed by network and/or transport layer without involving applications, which makes modifications to application programs completely unnecessary. I have already confirmed that ftp PORT command work transparently.
Of course the real world is nowhere close to ideal and personally SIP phones and Jabber clients are the only things I've ever observed widely using SRV records,
As we can explicitly specify port numbers in URLs, support for SRV is not very essential. But, SRV will be more commonly used as PCP will be deployed. Masataka Ohta
Current thread:
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query), (continued)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) Masataka Ohta (Sep 06)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) Owen DeLong (Sep 06)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) Eliot Lear (Sep 10)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) Owen DeLong (Sep 11)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) Masataka Ohta (Sep 11)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) valdis . kletnieks (Sep 06)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) Mark Andrews (Sep 06)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) valdis . kletnieks (Sep 06)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) Sean Harlow (Sep 06)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) Owen DeLong (Sep 06)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) Masataka Ohta (Sep 06)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) Mark Andrews (Sep 06)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) valdis . kletnieks (Sep 07)
- Re: The End-To-End Internet (was Re: Blocking MX query) Rich Kulawiec (Sep 08)