nanog mailing list archives
Re: "Illegal content" (Re: Megaupload.com seized)
From: Valdis.Kletnieks () vt edu
Date: Fri, 20 Jan 2012 14:07:29 -0500
On Fri, 20 Jan 2012 12:46:51 CST, Robert Bonomi said:
Sorry, but the last sentence is simply _not_ true. If the making of the copy was a violation of 17 USC 106 (1) or (2), it's existance is proscribed by law.
Nice try, but reading 17 USC 503 (b) we see: "As part of a final judgment or decree, the court may order the destruction or other reasonable disposition of all copies or phonorecords found to have been made or used in violation of the copyright owner's exclusive rights, and of all plates, molds, matrices, masters, tapes, film negatives, or other articles by means of which such copies or phonorecords may be reproduced." Note - the court *may* order the destruction. It's not mandatory. And there's no implied mandatory destruction elsewhere - if there was, 503(b) wouldn't need to exist because the destruction would already be required, so a court couldn't order additional destruction.
Attachment:
_bin
Description:
Current thread:
- Re: Megaupload.com seized, (continued)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Roland Perry (Jan 20)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Tei (Jan 20)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Alec Muffett (Jan 20)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Tei (Jan 20)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Jacob Taylor (Jan 22)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Tei (Jan 24)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Valdis . Kletnieks (Jan 20)
- "Illegal content" (Re: Megaupload.com seized) Carsten Bormann (Jan 20)
- Re: "Illegal content" (Re: Megaupload.com seized) Marshall Eubanks (Jan 20)
- Re: "Illegal content" (Re: Megaupload.com seized) Robert Bonomi (Jan 20)
- Re: "Illegal content" (Re: Megaupload.com seized) Valdis . Kletnieks (Jan 20)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Owen DeLong (Jan 20)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized bmanning (Jan 20)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Vadim Antonov (Jan 20)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Jay Ashworth (Jan 20)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Jeroen van Aart (Jan 31)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Michael Painter (Jan 19)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Ricky Beam (Jan 20)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Paul Graydon (Jan 20)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Tony McCrory (Jan 20)
- Re: Megaupload.com seized Leo Bicknell (Jan 20)