nanog mailing list archives
Re: [routing-wg] The Cidr Report
From: Graham Beneke <graham () apolix co za>
Date: Sun, 16 Oct 2011 09:05:25 +0200
On 15/10/2011 21:25, Geoff Huston wrote:
Does anyone give a s**t about this any more?
I do. While most of the content of the actual mail has very little relevance to me, it does provide useful leverage and motivation to fix some of the networks where I do have influence.
From what I learned at the latest NANOG it's very clear that nobody reads this any more.
I often don't have the time to read every report in detail and much of it applies to networks outside of my circles. Every few weeks it does however prompt me to go and review my own network (and sometimes wave a stick at few ops people)
Is there any good reason to persist in spamming the nanog list with this report?
I definitely think its still useful for the community. Perhaps the frequency could be dialed back a little? I'm sure that there are many people who don't really notice it any more due to their mental white noise filters.
Perhaps some slightly different presentations of the data would also make it more useful. I am quite interested in the number of prefixes of various lengths that are seen in the table and that doesn't get included in the mailed report.
Perhaps a "biggest climbers & fallers" list would also have more relevance for the regular report. The "Top 30" list doesn't seem to change very often... ;-)
-- Graham Beneke
Current thread:
- The Cidr Report cidr-report (Oct 07)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- The Cidr Report cidr-report (Oct 14)
- Re: [routing-wg] The Cidr Report Geoff Huston (Oct 15)
- Re: [routing-wg] The Cidr Report Randy Bush (Oct 15)
- Re: [routing-wg] The Cidr Report Patrick W. Gilmore (Oct 15)
- [routing-wg] The Cidr Report Kyle Creyts (Oct 15)
- Re: [routing-wg] The Cidr Report James McMurry (Oct 15)
- Re: [routing-wg] The Cidr Report Geoff Huston (Oct 15)
- Re: [routing-wg] The Cidr Report Geoff Huston (Oct 15)
- Re: [routing-wg] The Cidr Report Simon Leinen (Oct 15)
- Re: [routing-wg] The Cidr Report Hank Nussbacher (Oct 15)
- Re: [routing-wg] The Cidr Report Graham Beneke (Oct 16)
- Re: [routing-wg] The Cidr Report Jay Ashworth (Oct 16)
- Re: [routing-wg] The Cidr Report Bjoern A. Zeeb (Oct 16)