nanog mailing list archives

Re: IP4 Space


From: Owen DeLong <owen () delong com>
Date: Thu, 11 Mar 2010 12:04:31 -0800


On Mar 11, 2010, at 10:16 AM, Bill Bogstad wrote:

On Wed, Mar 10, 2010 at 10:00 PM, Daniel Senie <dts () senie com> wrote:
Well, it's like this... there's still no native IPv6 connectivity in most data centers, residences, >businesses or wireless, most vendors of networking equipment have not had a lot of mileage on >their IPv6 code if they even have it fully working, and, frankly, the IPv6 community has been >predicting a falling sky for so long that people just gave up listening. Add in a whole lot of other bits >of argument that just exasperate those dealing with today's problems, and it's pretty easy to >understand, if you've not been one of the ones pushing IPV6 for all these years, that there's a lot of >listener fatigue.

I fall into this category, but I'm trying to get better.  This may be
OT for this forum, but as someone whose network admin hat has mostly
been at the LAN/MAN level, I'm less concerned about IPv6 peering, etc.
then I am with what applications/servers don't play well with IPv6 and
how do I work around those issues.  Where does one go to find out how
organizations have switched their internal IT infrastructure to IPv6?
Does it make sense/work to do this for internal operations even if our
outside connections are IPv4 only (forget about tunneling).  Even more
mundane questions like how to deal with IPv4 only networked printers
when everything else is IPv6?

First, it's best not to approach this as switching to IPv6. Think of it, instead,
for now, as adding IPv6 capability to as much of your IPv4 environment
as possible.

I don't know of any applications which are negatively impacted by having
IPv6 capabilities. Several end-user applications do not play well if you remove their IPv4 capabilities, although that is getting fixed for the most
popular internet-oriented ones fairly quickly.

The most important things to get on dual stack initially all play well.
These would include your internet-facing services such as your
mail gateway, web servers, etc.

If anyone in the Boston metro area wants to present to the local
system administrators group
(www.bblisa.org) on why we should care (and more importantly what to
do) please contact me off list.   We're mostly a bunch of senior Unix
system administrator who are comfortable in our IPv4 world
and (I think) see IPv6 as a whole bunch of work to mostly get back to
where we already are.  We've all heard about the coming address
apocalypse, but it always seems somewhere in the distant future.

If you can get 50 people or more in the room, I'd be happy to come
present to your group.  Hurricane Electric will pay my travel.

Owen



Current thread: