nanog mailing list archives
Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP
From: Andrew Thrift <andrew () networklabs co nz>
Date: Fri, 18 Jun 2010 02:40:04 +1200
I work with networking products from all of the mentioned vendors on a daily basis. HP Networking (was ProCurve) make a solid SME switching product, it is comparable to Cisco 2000/3000 series switches, they also have chassis switches such as the 54xx/82xx, however these lack a lot of the more advanced features available from Cisco and Juniper, and have significant hardware limitations e.g. backplane bandwidth. HP also do not have decent stackable switches, which will be a concern if you want to split LACP trunks across multiple switches/chassis.> From a technical point of view, I have never worked in a shop that used HP or 3Com for the infrastructure. Dot-com's, telco's, bank's, hosting companies...I haven't seen any of them using 3com or HP. Additionally, I'm not fond of having to deal with a third set of equipment. I'm not exactly comfortable going with HP, but I'd like some data to help resolve the debate.
Another major negative with the HP gear for us is that their switches only support SFP/SFP+ modules manufactured by HP, so those SFP+ Twin-AX cables that came with your Dell/IBM Blade chassis will be useless to connect to your HP Switches, to add insult HP often sell their own modules at 3x the price of an equivalent module from say Extreme or Juniper.
So my questions to the NANOG community are: Would you recommend HP over Cisco or Juniper? How is HP's functionality and performance compared to Cisco or Juniper? Does anyone have any HP networking experiences they can share, good or bad?
My reccomendation would be, use Juniper for Core and Aggregation with ProCurve at the edge.
Regards, Andrew
Current thread:
- Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP James Smith (Jun 17)
- RE: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Brandon Kim (Jun 17)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Andrew D Kirch (Jun 17)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Jack Carrozzo (Jun 17)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Andrew Thrift (Jun 17)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Jack Carrozzo (Jun 17)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Andrew Thrift (Jun 17)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Eugen Leitl (Jun 17)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Jeff Kell (Jun 17)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Bill Blackford (Jun 17)
- RE: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Dylan Ebner (Jun 17)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Tom (Jun 17)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Tom Ammon (Jun 17)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Greg Whynott (Jun 17)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Colin Alston (Jun 23)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Matthew Walster (Jun 24)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Carl Rosevear (Jun 24)
- Re: Advice regarding Cisco/Juniper/HP Tom Ammon (Jun 17)