nanog mailing list archives
Re: Software router state of the art
From: Charles Wyble <charles () thewybles com>
Date: Mon, 28 Jul 2008 11:05:10 -0700
Seth Mattinen wrote:
michael.dillon () bt com wrote:but knowing how bad Linux is at being a router and that their products are Linux-based, I'm afraid to give one a try. J products are based on a competing non-Linux platform that has a better reputation for routing.Thanks for being oh-so-helpful with a serious question. Got any useful answers for me? Give me a vendor that offers your suggestion. I don't have time for a make-it-myself solution.
Hmmmm. Well then you probably don't want to use Linux/BSD as a router, as a substantial amount of DIY is required for anything beyond relatively simple routing. MPLS support (on Linux) for example is in early phases and requires integrating separate pieces and is best supported on Fedora9. Needless to say, Fedora isn't designed for reliable/stable operation and long term deployment.
I have yet to look into *BSD based solutions, but hear very good things about firewall performance. I don't know about BGP/OSPF/MPLS etc support on FreeBSD but am going to wager a guess its on par with Linux if not better.
To address another point made in this thread, see http://ols.fedoraproject.org/OLS/Reprints-2007/zhu-Reprint.pdf which addresses hardware multiqueue device support under Linux. Its from 2007. I think there was a question about Linux/multiqueue support in this thread, but I am not 100% sure. :)
I think there was mention of Vyatta earlier in the thread and some talk about it switching from Xorp to Quagga, and a supposition that should improve it.
-- Charles Wyble (818) 280 - 7059 http://charlesnw.blogspot.com CTO Known Element Enterprises / SoCal WiFI project
Current thread:
- Re: Software router state of the art, (continued)
- Re: Software router state of the art Joe Greco (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Rubens Kuhl Jr. (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Eugeniu Patrascu (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Seth Mattinen (Jul 28)
- RE: Software router state of the art michael.dillon (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Justin Sharp (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Andrew D Kirch (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Charles Wyble (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art David E. Smith (Jul 29)
- Re: Software router state of the art Seth Mattinen (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Charles Wyble (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Joe Greco (Jul 28)
- Message not available
- Re: Software router state of the art Seth Mattinen (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Deepak Jain (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Chris Stebner (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Jack Bates (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Chris Stebner (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Deepak Jain (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Christopher Morrow (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Kevin Day (Jul 28)
- Re: Software router state of the art Aaron Glenn (Jul 28)