nanog mailing list archives
RE: shim6 @ NANOG
From: "Tony Hain" <alh-ietf () tndh net>
Date: Tue, 7 Mar 2006 17:27:22 -0800
Paul Jakma wrote:
On Tue, 7 Mar 2006, Iljitsch van Beijnum wrote:Hm, I would rather do this globally but maybe this is the way to go...Geo-aggregation is something that stands its best chance of being implemented locally:
While I agree that any aggregation would happen locally, the overall allocation policy for a consistent geo approach needs to be done globally.
- the 'players' involved will be fewer - requirements for a workable policy will be easier to work out (and fewer conflicts between requirements) - there may be existing 'arbiter of last resort' (particularly at national levels) to resolve the inevitable conflicts. Ie this may be best done even /below/ the RIR level (though, RIR agreement would be needed). Still though, hard to see it happening without some acceptance by operators.
You are mixing issues here. A policy for assigning PI space is what ARIN can deal with. A deployment agreement about aggregating a collection of PI assignments is what operators can deal with. What needs to happen is to define a global mechanism for PI assignments such that it is possible to do aggregations when it becomes necessary. Any of the geo approaches allows aggregation of a high-density pocket without requiring aggregation of all pockets globally. In particular the approach I have been pursuing allows the definition of any aggregate to evolve and track population shifts over time. Tony
Current thread:
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG, (continued)
- Message not available
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Iljitsch van Beijnum (Mar 06)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Owen DeLong (Mar 05)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Joe Abley (Mar 05)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Stephen Sprunk (Mar 05)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Joe Abley (Mar 05)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Roland Dobbins (Mar 05)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Iljitsch van Beijnum (Mar 06)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Owen DeLong (Mar 06)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Iljitsch van Beijnum (Mar 07)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Paul Jakma (Mar 07)
- RE: shim6 @ NANOG Tony Hain (Mar 07)
- RE: shim6 @ NANOG Paul Jakma (Mar 07)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Owen DeLong (Mar 07)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG John Curran (Mar 07)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Edward B. DREGER (Mar 07)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Owen DeLong (Mar 07)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Tony Li (Mar 05)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Steven M. Bellovin (Mar 05)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Iljitsch van Beijnum (Mar 06)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG Stephen Sprunk (Mar 06)
- Re: shim6 @ NANOG David Meyer (Mar 06)