nanog mailing list archives
Re: NLB Recommendations
From: "John Neiberger" <John.Neiberger () efirstbank com>
Date: Wed, 09 Jun 2004 10:33:44 -0600
I'm looking for recommendations for network load balancers. These, at this time, will primarily be used to attach to a cluster of
webservers
although I would like a solution which can be repurposed to other applications later. I am looking at F5's Big IP, Cisco's SLB, and Foundry's ServerIron at this time.
We have Cisco 11503s and F5 Big IPs in our network. I bought the Big IPs because I was getting rather fed up with the Cisco stuff. Each has their quirks but I think I prefer the F5, especially for box-to-box redundancy. That's really rough with the Cisco gear unless you want to fork out a lot of cash for their ridiculously expensive ethernet modules so you can get a direct box-to-box connection. If you have load-balanced servers behind an F5 that also must be available for direct connection, then the F5 is a huge pain, while that is extremely simple with the Cisco gear. Other than that, I think I the F5 is a better product and easier to manage once you get used to how it works. If you've previously used the Cisco gear, you have to unlearn a few concepts and terms in order to make sense of the F5 world. Regards, John --
Current thread:
- NLB Recommendations James Baldwin (Jun 08)
- Re: NLB Recommendations Tine (Jun 09)
- Re: NLB Recommendations Mike Lyon (Jun 09)
- Re: NLB Recommendations Joe Abley (Jun 10)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- RE: NLB Recommendations Burton, Chris (Jun 08)
- RE: NLB Recommendations Gordon, Michael (Jun 09)
- Re: NLB Recommendations John Neiberger (Jun 09)
- Re: NLB Recommendations Charles Sprickman (Jun 09)
- Re: NLB Recommendations John Neiberger (Jun 09)
- Re: NLB Recommendations Keith Washington (Jun 09)
- Charter blocking Port 25 Arman (Jun 09)
- Re: Charter blocking Port 25 Matthew McGehrin (Jun 09)
- Re: Charter blocking Port 25 Deepak Jain (Jun 09)
- Re: Charter blocking Port 25 W. Mark Herrick, Jr. (Jun 09)
- Re: Charter blocking Port 25 Gregory (Grisha) Trubetskoy (Jun 09)
- Re: Charter blocking Port 25 Richard Parker (Jun 09)
- Re: Charter blocking Port 25 Gregory (Grisha) Trubetskoy (Jun 10)