RE: [OT] Re: Banned on NANOG

[Alex Rubenstein <alex () nac net>]

I am going out on a limb here, and leaving lurk mode on this issue. If I 
get banned, well, Randy and I can start our own mailing list. We're as 
about as grumpy as each other.

I disagree with William entirely. Suspensions are idiotic, and only 
detract from the usefulness of the list. S:N is important, but so is being 
an human being.

People are people; we are not robots. This list serves a specific purpose, 
as does anything in life. Sometimes people do things with stuff that is 
out of bounds with said stuff, but, again, people make mistakes.

We're not in school, we don't need suspensions. We need to act like 
adults, use this list for it's intended purpose. If someone is a dodo for 
a message or two here or there, then, well, we tolerate it and move on, 
maybe someone on the list sends that person an email saying, "Dude, your 
email was dopey, please stop." If the person continues to be a dodo, get 
rid of the problem. It's as simple as that. I think we all agree that RAS 
and Randy don't fall into the above category of having to be gotten ridden 
of. Again, it's all relative.

So, go ahead and ask, "But, that won't work, will it?"

My rebutt: It's how inet-access (people from 1993 to 2000 or so will know 
what this is) worked, and, well, except for the very occasional whack-job, 
it worked well. It was a useful list. The reason it died had nothing to do 
with S:N on that list; it had to do with the fact that the industry 
supporting that list more or less evaporated.

Disagree with me, perhaps I didn't even make sense; perhaps that tells you 
about how much sleep I've gotten recently, or the insanity of this entire 
situation.




On Thu, 2 Dec 2004, william(at)elan.net wrote:

> I think to be more fair it would be good if suspensions were not
> permanent but for period of time (with period doubling or tripling on
> subsequent suspensions if it happens). At least people will not be
> as upset when they are suspended and know its just a period for them
> to calm down and do more reading of nanog then posting...
>
> --
> William Leibzon
> Elan Networks
> william () elan net

-- Alex Rubenstein, AR97, K2AHR, alex () nac net, latency, Al Reuben --
--    Net Access Corporation, 800-NET-ME-36, http://www.nac.net   --