nanog mailing list archives
Re: whois broke again?
From: William Allen Simpson <wsimpson () greendragon com>
Date: Sun, 20 Feb 2000 15:51:16 -0500
"Roeland M.J. Meyer" wrote:
Then I suggest that you do. I wouldn't sign the NDA, but you might.
What NDA? It's draft-hollenbeck-rrp-01.txt. But this is irrelevant to the whois discussion.
With SRS, this is no longer possible as the whois data is already distributed among NSI's channel market, the Registrars. Each are independent entities. The only real target you have to fire at is the ICANN. GFL ... they're broke.
I think we must be talking at cross purposes. The domain whois data is located in whois servers, maintained by the NSI registry. It is updated by registrars. The NSI registry whois seems to be falling down and cannot get up. We need a good system of distributed whois servers, just as we have a robust system of distributed DNS servers. We've talked about this before. Rather than complaining about NSI, folk need to get off their duffs and make it happen. I don't have the kind of bandwidth that we should have at the whois servers, so I cannnot offer space. All I can do is chearlead (and write code). Are we lacking an incremental distribution protocol for whois? What about rwhois? (RFC-2167 Informational) What about whois++? (RFC-1913 & 1914 Proposed Standards) WSimpson () UMich edu Key fingerprint = 17 40 5E 67 15 6F 31 26 DD 0D B9 9B 6A 15 2C 32
Current thread:
- whois broke again? Brad (Feb 19)
- Re: whois broke again? Kevin Day (Feb 19)
- Re: whois broke again? NANOG Mailing List (Feb 19)
- Re: whois broke again? Alex Rubenstein (Feb 19)
- Re: whois broke again? John Hawkinson (Feb 19)
- Re: whois broke again? Valdis . Kletnieks (Feb 19)
- Re: whois broke again? NANOG Mailing List (Feb 19)
- RE: whois broke again? Roeland M.J. Meyer (Feb 19)
- Re: whois broke again? William Allen Simpson (Feb 20)
- RE: whois broke again? Roeland M.J. Meyer (Feb 20)
- Re: whois broke again? William Allen Simpson (Feb 20)
- Re: whois broke again? Rodney Joffe (Feb 20)
- Re: whois broke again? William Allen Simpson (Feb 20)
- Re: whois broke again? bmanning (Feb 20)
- Re: whois broke again? William Allen Simpson (Feb 20)
- Re: whois broke again? bmanning (Feb 21)
- Re: whois broke again? NANOG Mailing List (Feb 19)
- Re: whois broke again? Kevin Day (Feb 19)
- Re: whois broke again? Rodney Joffe (Feb 20)
- Re: whois broke again? Paul Vixie (Feb 21)
- RE: whois broke again? Roeland M.J. Meyer (Feb 20)
- RE: whois broke again? Mr. James W. Laferriere (Feb 20)
- RE: whois broke again? Patrick Greenwell (Feb 21)