nanog mailing list archives

Re: New Federal Law (COPPA)


From: "Henry R. Linneweh" <linneweh () concentric net>
Date: Fri, 21 Apr 2000 23:48:11 -0700


Then such a law is unconstitutional since it openly discriminates against
a particular age group and was crafted with such intent in mind,  as to
deter the use of an informational instrument and network pathways
for personal growth of A said class of people in the United States.

Shawn McMahon wrote:

It's worse than that.

Giving something away in a contest that's illegal in Florida?

Sorry, can't ask what state they're from without parental permission.

Need their email address for password verification?  Sorry.

Effectively, this bars children from accessing the net, since companies
won't be able to affordably comply.

And all to protect children from something that their parents can far more
effectively protect them against.

On Fri, 21 Apr 2000, Andrew Brown wrote:

i have a website that might be collecting information from children,
even though that's not the "target" audience.  can i ask the person
how old they are, or is that a violation of the law?

it seems to me that i must break the law in order to comply.

--
Thank you;
|--------------------------------------------|
| Thinking is a learned process so is UNIX   |
|--------------------------------------------|
Henry R. Linneweh





Current thread: