Re: RBL Update (Re: Lets go vixie!! rbl)

[Paul Vixie <vixie () wisdom rc vix com>]

> > The agreement Paul Vixie makes RBL users sign states that EXPLICITLY.

No.

> > You are not allowed to use the RBL unless you disclose such use fully to
> > your customers and/or downstreams.

There is apparently some ambiguity surrounding my use of the verb "publish"
in the RBL Subscriber Agreement.  I will see that this is fixed in V2.1.

> "Makes"... makes how?  I simply enabled it in my sendmail configs and ran
> with it. Didn't even SEE where it mentioned that I *HAD* to go agree to
> stuff.

There is no requirement that anyone sign a license if they aren't subscribing,
where "subscribing" means receiving it as an eBGP4 or DNS "feed".  If you're
using "FEATURE(rbl)" in sendmail 8.9.0, or a similar feature of other mailers,
you're using the RBL but you're not a subscriber (and more power to you).

> Dunno what the solution is, but I can see a somewhat real problem here.

The first line of complaint is the ISP who uses the RBL.  If someone turns it
on without notifying their customers / downstreams, they'll hear about it
right quick.
-- 
Paul Vixie
La Honda, CA                    "Many NANOG members have been around
<paul () vix com>                        longer than most." --Jim Fleming
pacbell!vixie!paul               (An H.323 GateKeeper for the IPv8 Network)