nanog mailing list archives
Re: WorldNIC
From: "Jay R. Ashworth" <jra () scfn thpl lib fl us>
Date: Tue, 9 Jun 1998 15:55:32 -0400
On Tue, Jun 09, 1998 at 12:34:56PM -0700, Michael Dillon wrote:
On Tue, 9 Jun 1998, Jay R. Ashworth wrote:How does providing different top level domains for different categories of organizations "violate the laws of physics", Michael?It tries to confine objects to a single state whereas physics teaches that the universe cannot be so neatly sliced and diced.
Taxonomy isn't a physical science, is it?
Of course, I could have simply asked the question that needs to be asked, namely: why would anyone want a name to include a category anyway?
Because people in different categories want "the same name". It's a convenient divisor. DNS names are actually _addresses_, and can't be expected to map one to one with names in the large; this is an attempt to soften the impact of that problem. But you already knew that, no?
Your name, Jay Ashworth, gives no clue as to your education, your training, your profession, your age, your race, your height. Why should an Internet domain name be any different? The DNS needs to be hierarchical so that a query can trace a path from the root of the DNS to find the IP address belonging to a name. But why should the branches in the hierarchy mean anything in particular in any given human language?
Because that's the way people _think_? If I'm looking for the Coca Cola Drinkers Club, it's obvious to someone who knows what the tags _are_ that that will be at cocacola.org, not cocacola.com, Coke's lawyers notwithstanding.
Some people would like to restrict .com to COMMON usage, .org to ORGASMIC providers and .net to CLEAN content (net is French for clean), but I personally don't give a damn and prefer a more diverse and chaotic system of naming.
I know you made those up out of thin air, but still.. If you want a real answer as to how this should be done, ask a librarian. And the fact that that's my recommendation should say something all by itself. Cheers, -- jra -- Jay R. Ashworth jra () baylink com Member of the Technical Staff Unsolicited Commercial Emailers Sued The Suncoast Freenet "Two words: Darth Doogie." -- Jason Colby, Tampa Bay, Florida on alt.fan.heinlein +1 813 790 7592 Managing Editor, Top Of The Key sports e-zine ------------ http://www.totk.com
Current thread:
- Re: WorldNIC, (continued)
- Message not available
- Re: WorldNIC Jay R. Ashworth (Jun 08)
- Re: WorldNIC Jon Lewis (Jun 08)
- Re: WorldNIC Greg Simpson (Jun 08)
- Re: WorldNIC Jon Lewis (Jun 08)
- Re: WorldNIC Dean Robb (Jun 08)
- Re: WorldNIC Michael Shields (Jun 08)
- Message not available
- Re: WorldNIC Jay R. Ashworth (Jun 09)
- Re: WorldNIC Michael Dillon (Jun 09)
- Message not available
- Re: WorldNIC Jay R. Ashworth (Jun 09)
- Re: WorldNIC Michael Dillon (Jun 09)
- Message not available
- Re: WorldNIC Jay R. Ashworth (Jun 09)
- Re: WorldNIC James R. Cutler (Jun 10)
- Re: WorldNIC Aled Morris (Jun 09)
- Re: WorldNIC Dean Robb (Jun 11)
- Re: WorldNIC Michael Dillon (Jun 11)
- Message not available
- Re: WorldNIC Dean Robb (Jun 11)
- Re: WorldNIC Roeland M.J. Meyer (Jun 11)
- Re: WorldNIC just me. (Jun 12)
- Re: WorldNIC just me. (Jun 12)
- Re: WorldNIC Jon Lewis (Jun 09)
- Re: WorldNIC Steve Sobol (Jun 10)