Security Basics mailing list archives

RE: Different AV Prouducts


From: "Eddy Alexandre" <EddyA () nichemediallc com>
Date: Wed, 13 Aug 2008 13:55:00 -0400

What about AVG Antivirus.  I had great results with them? 
Anything against using them?

Kind regards,
 
Eddy Alexandre
Dir. Information Technology
Niche Media
www.nichemediallc.com

 -----Original Message-----
From: listbounce () securityfocus com [mailto:listbounce () securityfocus com]
On Behalf Of Andy Cuff (Talisker)
Sent: Wednesday, August 13, 2008 12:07 PM
To: pthroumoulos () rochester rr com; security-basics () securityfocus com
Subject: RE: Different AV Prouducts

I would strongly suggest reconsidering your options and escalating your
issue with Symantec.  You may face the same support issues with another
AV vendor, in addition to trying to integrate a new AV into your
enterprise.

I'm not advocating Symantec over Sophos or Kapersky, I'm just
considering the impact of the change.  I

Regards

Andy Cuff
Computer Network Defence Ltd
www.SecurityWizardry.com

I was wondering if anybody could provide me with any positive 
information about switching from Symantec Corporate Edition
(10.1.4.4000) to any other AV products. I have looked at a couple 
different solutions but am by no means a security guru and would 
appreciate any feedback I could get that would help persuade me to 
switch to a different solution. The two other products that I am 
considering are Kaspersky or Sophos.
Reason I picked these two is that I have seen quite a few emails 
bounced back and forth about the quality of both of these products 
compared to Symantec. Obviously all AV products are going to be better

at certain things than others such as detection and removal. All I am 
looking for is a product that I can implement on about 180+ clients 
and about 30 servers that will be easily managed and not have too 
large of a foot print and I do not want to have to visit every client 
to remove the old AV before deploying the new solution.

One of the reasons I would like to switch from Symantec to another 
product is that just recently I had to deal with their tech support 
for an issue we were experiencing on our clients. My experience with 
tech support has left me very jaded as it took them almost three weeks

to figure out the problem.

The issue we were experiencing was when a user would log into their 
desktop explorer.exe would not load and they would only see their 
wallpaper (All dell machines) The solution to the issue was to turn of

"tamper protection"

on all the clients, though this did solve the issue I am still a 
little concerned about the fact that you need to turn off any 
component of any AV product. I also feel like Symantec does not do the

best job at detection of other types of malware besides viruses. 
Several times this year I had several infected clients that I had to 
rebuild because Symantec did not detect the issues till it was too 
late to do anything. If anybody could point me in the right direction 
to getting more info on a better AV solution than Symantec I would 
greatly appreciate it.








Current thread: