nanog mailing list archives
Re: SIP on FTTH systems
From: Mark Tinka <mark.tinka () seacom mu>
Date: Thu, 6 Feb 2014 16:42:46 +0200
On Thursday, February 06, 2014 04:17:42 PM Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
You don't need a BNG. You need an L3 switch as the first hop the customer is talking to.
Fine for FTTB, but not for FTTH where you're serving tens- to-hundreds-of-thousands of customers. If your FTTH deployments are low scale (measure of low or large scale depends on each operator's point of view), the case for doing without subscriber management technologies can be made.
If you have L3-in-vlan-per-customer at the first hop then you don't really need all of that. If you include rudimentary VRF support then you can even support wholesale. /64 per customer, DHCPv6(-PD) server support in the L3 switch and you're good to go.
I'm curious; in these deployments, what kind of customer scale are you talking about? When someone says FTTH, I'm thinking thousands and thousands of customers, in which case not having a scalable susbcriber management system as well as not having a scalable customer termination topology could be difficult. Unless I misunderstand...
There is equipment that already claim to do this (I never got to test their implementation based on my requirements because I switched jobs, but they claimed to have implemented everything last year).
Modern Metro-E switches that support full IP/MPLS in the Access have a lot of good IPv4 and IPv6 features, including DHCP_IA and DHCP_IA_PD, but again, these are more FTTB- than FTTH-focused, if you're talking about scale. Cheers, Mark.
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
Current thread:
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems, (continued)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mark Tinka (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mikael Abrahamsson (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mark Tinka (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Jean-Francois Mezei (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mikael Abrahamsson (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mark Tinka (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Jay Ashworth (Feb 07)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Anders Löwinger (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mark Tinka (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mikael Abrahamsson (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mark Tinka (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mikael Abrahamsson (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mark Tinka (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Anders Löwinger (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mikael Abrahamsson (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mark Tinka (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Anders Löwinger (Feb 07)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mikael Abrahamsson (Feb 07)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mark Tinka (Feb 06)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Anders Löwinger (Feb 07)
- Re: SIP on FTTH systems Mark Tinka (Feb 07)