nanog mailing list archives
Re: De-funding the ITU
From: George Herbert <george.herbert () gmail com>
Date: Mon, 14 Jan 2013 15:23:40 -0800
On Mon, Jan 14, 2013 at 7:27 AM, John Levine <johnl () iecc com> wrote:
There'd have to be some organization to negotiate and oversee international settlements and other, similar, regulations.Why? The internet has operated just fine without such for quite some time now.The Internet is held together with spit and duct tape, and sucks for connections that need a stable low-jitter channel, we've all noticed. It has no principle of universal service. The Internet does what it does surprisingly well, but it's not the same kind of network as the phone system. We all know of the abuses that can come with mandatory interconnection and settlements, but the solution is not to cut off the poor countries.
I'm not sure that this mythical "kind of network as the phone system" allegedly is describes the reality of the phone network... That said, two comments: 1. I generally agree that the Internet has too much spit and duct tape, however; 2. Siccing the ITU on that problem - or allowing them near it - would be a disaster of a magnitude not often seen in human affairs. -- -george william herbert george.herbert () gmail com
Current thread:
- Re: De-funding the ITU, (continued)
- Re: De-funding the ITU John Levine (Jan 14)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Nick Hilliard (Jan 14)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Wayne E Bouchard (Jan 14)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Eliot Lear (Jan 14)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Owen DeLong (Jan 14)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Bill Woodcock (Jan 14)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Nick Hilliard (Jan 14)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Owen DeLong (Jan 14)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Nick Hilliard (Jan 15)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Eric Brunner-Williams (Jan 14)
- Re: De-funding the ITU George Herbert (Jan 14)
- Re: De-funding the ITU John R. Levine (Jan 14)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Eric Brunner-Williams (Jan 13)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Dave Crocker (Jan 13)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Eliot Lear (Jan 13)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Owen DeLong (Jan 14)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Dave Crocker (Jan 13)
- Re: De-funding the ITU John R. Levine (Jan 13)
- Re: De-funding the ITU Jimmy Hess (Jan 13)