nanog mailing list archives
Re: what about 48 bits?
From: Roland Perry <lists () internetpolicyagency com>
Date: Wed, 7 Apr 2010 11:43:41 +0100
In article <201004071023.o37ANtww018405 () aurora sol net>, Joe Greco <jgreco () ns sol net> writes
interoperability and backwards compatibility were the tipping points.Ah, yes, backwards compatibility: implementing the fantastic feature of breaking the network...
By "backwards compatibility" I mean the ability to use the new LAN from a laptop that didn't have an Ethernet connection built in, and didn't have an optional [proprietary] internal Ethernet card available either.
Later on, of course, you would get PCMCIA cards and USB dongles rather than Centronics-port dongles. But the market for these remained dominated by the Ethernet standard, rather than others.
we all remember the fun of what happened when someone incorrectly unhooked a 10base2 network segment; D-Link managed to one-up that on the theoretically more-robust 10baseT/UTP by introducing a card that'd break your network when you powered off the attached PC.
That tale of woe doesn't really sound like it's the fault of backwards compatibility. Didn't the operational status of the LAX immigration department fall to zero for almost a whole day, once; as a result of a rogue network card crashing the LAN?
-- Roland Perry
Current thread:
- Re: what about 48 bits?, (continued)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Jeroen van Aart (Apr 07)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Vince Fuller (Apr 08)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Barry Shein (Apr 05)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Steven Bellovin (Apr 05)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Bill Stewart (Apr 05)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Stephen Sprunk (Apr 06)
- Re: what about 48 bits? joel jaeggli (Apr 06)
- Re: what about 48 bits? John Kristoff (Apr 07)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Roland Perry (Apr 07)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Joe Greco (Apr 07)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Roland Perry (Apr 07)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Joe Greco (Apr 07)
- Hubs on a NIC (was:Re: what about 48 bits?) Lamar Owen (Apr 07)
- Re: Hubs on a NIC (was:Re: what about 48 bits?) Joe Greco (Apr 07)
- Re: Hubs on a NIC (was:Re: what about 48 bits?) Steven Bellovin (Apr 07)
- Re: Hubs on a NIC (was:Re: what about 48 bits?) Joe Greco (Apr 08)
- Re: Hubs on a NIC (was:Re: what about 48 bits?) Roland Perry (Apr 08)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Michael Thomas (Apr 07)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Michael Thomas (Apr 07)
- Re: what about 48 bits? Roland Perry (Apr 08)
- Re: what about 48 bits? A.B. Jr. (Apr 04)