nanog mailing list archives
Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested
From: Randy Bush <randy () psg com>
Date: Mon, 8 Nov 2004 13:22:07 -0800
I must admint, I'm really not up on the more subtle aspects of v6 addressing nor have I read the drafts you posted, but I've never understood why we needed a new set of RFC1918-like IPv6 space.because there is not enough v6 address space? because we like nats?There's no PI (yet) for IPv6, so NAT becomes necessary again. People don't like to give up the independence they have in IPv4 world.because we think we can't get space?For non-ISPs this is fact, given that there is no PI (yet). ISPs are allowed to multihome and have their independent address space, other's are told to be happy with vendor lock-in. IPv6 won't fly like that. But that's no news, but still heads are sticking deeply in the sandbox, unfortunately.
let me see if i understand. you propose a technical cluster <bleep> with which we are already horrifyingly familiar to fix an administrative problem? have i got it right? randy
Current thread:
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested, (continued)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Iljitsch van Beijnum (Nov 15)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Måns Nilsson (Nov 11)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Randy Bush (Nov 11)
- RE: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Tony Hain (Nov 11)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Leo Bicknell (Nov 11)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Joe Abley (Nov 11)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Valdis . Kletnieks (Nov 11)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Eric Gauthier (Nov 08)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Randy Bush (Nov 08)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Daniel Roesen (Nov 08)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Randy Bush (Nov 08)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Daniel Roesen (Nov 08)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Sascha Lenz (Nov 08)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Steven M. Bellovin (Nov 08)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Ted Hardie (Nov 08)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Randy Bush (Nov 08)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Steven M. Bellovin (Nov 08)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Jeroen Massar (Nov 08)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Leo Bicknell (Nov 09)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Alex Bligh (Nov 09)
- Re: Important IPv6 Policy Issue -- Your Input Requested Måns Nilsson (Nov 10)