nanog mailing list archives
Re: no whois info ?
From: abuse () cabal org uk (Peter Corlett)
Date: Fri, 10 Dec 2004 12:19:40 +0000 (UTC)
Elmar K. Bins <elmi () 4ever de> wrote:
abuse () cabal org uk (Peter Corlett) wrote:
[...]
This tempts me to hack something into Exim that does a whois on previously-unseen sender domains, and give a deferral if the whois denies existence of the domain. Is this likely to have any meaningful effect?
No. It depends too much on (a) the registry and registrar for the domain (b) overall whois availability to that TLD (not everybody uses whois) (c) your connectivity to the whois servers involved (possibly more than one)
You have a point if I were attempting to do this for all TLDs, but at least for a first cut, I'm only interested in .com/.net. A single query of whois.crsnic.net (and not bothering to follow referrals) would be sufficient to determine the existence of the domain in whois. There's some awful tinpot domain registrars out there where you have to wonder if their whois server is on the end of a dialup link, but fortunately I'm not attempting to access those. Connectivity from here to the CRSNIC server is good and no worse than to any other server I may wish to query for purposes of black- or greylisting. -- The advice given me about Maglites is to hold it out sideways from yourself but at shoulder height, this makes the opponent think you are standing 3 foot to one side of reality. - Rob Adams in the Monastery
Current thread:
- Re: no whois info ?, (continued)
- Re: no whois info ? Janet Sullivan (Dec 12)
- Re: no whois info ? Steve Gibbard (Dec 12)
- Re: no whois info ? Alex Bligh (Dec 12)
- Re: no whois info ? Peter John Hill (Dec 09)
- Re: no whois info ? Raymond Dijkxhoorn (Dec 09)
- Re: no whois info ? Mike Tancsa (Dec 09)
- Re: no whois info ? Peter John Hill (Dec 09)
- Re: no whois info ? Elmar K. Bins (Dec 10)
- Re: no whois info ? william(at)elan.net (Dec 10)
- Re: no whois info ? Peter Corlett (Dec 10)
- Re: no whois info ? Suresh Ramasubramanian (Dec 10)
- Re: no whois info ? Eric Brunner-Williams in Portland Maine (Dec 10)
- Message not available
- RE: no whois info ? Mike Tancsa (Dec 09)