nanog mailing list archives
Re: Where are ATM NAPs going?
From: Leo Bicknell <bicknell () ufp org>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 22:12:07 -0500
On Mon, Dec 18, 2000 at 09:14:53PM -0500, John Fraizer wrote:
So, what you're saying is that I should tell all the folks that want to peer via ATM at CMH-IX (which supports 10/100/GE at this time) that they should get bent or get GigE, right? THANK YOU!
I had to go google search for this one, and I presume you mean http://www.cmh-ix.net/. If so, it's a good thing the operators made the wise decision to support GigE, otherwise they couldn't possibly expect to meet demand. :-) I do want to applaud the CMH-IX, not because it will be a major exchange point in the future of the Internet, but because it does keep local traffic local. This is a good thing that should be done more. While I won't suggest that CMH-IX should run an ATM (or other) layer two fabric, I know of many smaller ISP's in metro areas who all buy a DS-3 into the same frame relay or atm network so they can "private peer" for the cost of a PVC. This is sort of an "exchange without an exchange". So, should CMH-IX go ATM? Well, given the traffic levels I don't think you could collect enough in fees to pay for an ATM switch. On that basis, ATM is a poor choice. Again, it's a poor choice not because of the technology, but because of the price points and products available. -- Leo Bicknell - bicknell () ufp org Systems Engineer - Internetworking Engineer - CCIE 3440 Read TMBG List - tmbg-list-request () tmbg org, www.tmbg.org
Current thread:
- RE: Where are ATM NAPs going?, (continued)
- RE: Where are ATM NAPs going? Christian Kuhtz (Dec 18)
- RE: Where are ATM NAPs going? Jay Ford (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Reid Knuttila (Dec 18)
- RE: Where are ATM NAPs going? Christian Kuhtz (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Leo Bicknell (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? David Charlap (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Leo Bicknell (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Alex Rubenstein (Dec 19)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Leo Bicknell (Dec 19)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Stephen Sprunk (Dec 19)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? David Charlap (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? John Fraizer (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Leo Bicknell (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Marshall Eubanks (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? John Fraizer (Dec 19)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Omachonu Ogali (Dec 19)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? John Fraizer (Dec 19)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Shawn McMahon (Dec 19)
- RE: Where are ATM NAPs going? Bill Woodcock (Dec 19)