nanog mailing list archives
Re: Where are ATM NAPs going?
From: Leo Bicknell <bicknell () ufp org>
Date: Mon, 18 Dec 2000 20:36:22 -0500
On Mon, Dec 18, 2000 at 07:27:05PM -0500, David Charlap wrote:
If there were OC-48 or OC-192 ATM coming, and/or switches with the density to make that work it would have a future, but alas, that seems to not be in any vendors road map.My company (Marconi) makes such a switch: http://www.marconi.com/html/solutions/asx4000.htm Non-blocking OC-48c ATM interfaces have been shipping for some time now.
Yes for _switches_, yes, and even the ASX4000 doesn't have the density required. At a 40 gig switch, that's only, 16 ports of OC-48 non-blocking, which is well, non-interesting. Consider a successful NAP will have 80-120 connections, and you would want to be able to get them all into the network at OC-48 speed without having to go completely wild on the trunk side. Design that with your switch, tough job. Compare that to an Extreme 6816, which for half the cost can do 192 gige ports in a single chassis, with 128Gbps of bandwidth. Makes the 40 gig ATM switch seem, well, 1/4 as powerful. This is all academic though, neither Cisco nor Juniper make any ATM interfaces over OC-48 for a _ROUTER_, so even if the whole world wanted it, it couldn't be done today. This is the classic problem with ATM, good backbone (switch-to-switch) capabilities and performance, but no edge support. -- Leo Bicknell - bicknell () ufp org Systems Engineer - Internetworking Engineer - CCIE 3440 Read TMBG List - tmbg-list-request () tmbg org, www.tmbg.org
Current thread:
- Where are ATM NAPs going? Ben Buxton (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Jay Ford (Dec 18)
- RE: Where are ATM NAPs going? Christian Kuhtz (Dec 18)
- RE: Where are ATM NAPs going? Jay Ford (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Reid Knuttila (Dec 18)
- RE: Where are ATM NAPs going? Christian Kuhtz (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Jay Ford (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Leo Bicknell (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? David Charlap (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Leo Bicknell (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Alex Rubenstein (Dec 19)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Leo Bicknell (Dec 19)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Stephen Sprunk (Dec 19)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? David Charlap (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? John Fraizer (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Leo Bicknell (Dec 18)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Sean Donelan (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Marshall Eubanks (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Richard A. Steenbergen (Dec 18)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? John Fraizer (Dec 19)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? Omachonu Ogali (Dec 19)
- Re: Where are ATM NAPs going? John Fraizer (Dec 19)