nanog mailing list archives
Re: BBN Peering issues
From: mark () exodus net (Mark Tripod)
Date: Sat, 15 Aug 1998 16:05:10 -0700
This issue is of specific importance to any individual responsible for running an ISP. Just as in the legal field the outcome of this issue may set a precedence for future events that will severely impact anyone wanting to become a tier one provider. The Internet was founded on the principle of free interconnectivity between network segments. It is fundamentally important that these ideals be extended to the future of the Internet, if it is to have a future. No company should have the right to force another to pay for connectivity simply because the latter has not been around since the beginning or they are not a telco. The next company on BBN's hit list may be yours. Mark *** Disclaimer *** The opinions expressed here are just those, opinions. They are neither the offical statements of my employer or endorced as such. Michael Shields wrote:
In article <Pine.BSF.3.96.980815012720.27167B-100000 () workhorse iMach com>, "Forrest W. Christian" <forrestc () iMach com> wrote:After all, it's the BBN customers REQUESTING the data from exodus, not the other way around.This argument goes around and around every time. Unless you have a customer relationship with Exodus or BBN there is no point in arguing about what should happen with this particular case, and there is no point at all in arguing about what is the morally correct thing for the general case. The only way to determine the value of connecting network A to network B, in either sign or magnitude, is for A and B to negotiate a price, which may even be zero. And that's what's happening here, albeit in a unusually painful and visible way. If you have an opinion and are a customer of BBN or Exodus, tell them your opinion. Otherwise there is no need to care. -- Shields, CrossLink.
-- *************************************************************************** Mark Tripod - Senior Network Architect - Exodus Communications http://www.exodus.net - (888) 2-EXODUS - support () exodus net ASN 3967 - NASDAQ (EXDS) - Direct: (408) 346-2389
Current thread:
- Re: BBN Peering issues, (continued)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Karl Denninger (Aug 13)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Robert Bowman (Aug 13)
- Message not available
- Re: BBN Peering issues Jay R. Ashworth (Aug 13)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Dan Ritter (Aug 14)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Robert Bowman (Aug 14)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Dan Ritter (Aug 14)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Robert Bowman (Aug 14)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Forrest W. Christian (Aug 15)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Michael Shields (Aug 15)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Karl Denninger (Aug 15)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Mark Tripod (Aug 17)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Michael Shields (Aug 16)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Todd 'Mr Vendor Relations' Nagengast (Aug 16)
- Message not available
- Re: BBN Peering issues Jay R. Ashworth (Aug 17)
- Re: BBN Peering issues Jon Zeeff (Aug 18)
- Message not available
- Re: BBN Peering issues Jay R. Ashworth (Aug 13)
- Re: BBN Peering issues alex (Aug 12)
- Re: BBN Peering issues David Greenman (Aug 12)