nanog mailing list archives
Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers
From: Stan Hanks <stan () networkmercenaries com>
Date: Mon, 17 Nov 1997 09:18:19 -0600 (CST)
If you decide to start filtering out SPAM by blocking it from the source, do you end up becoming a content provider because you're controlling what your customers have access to? If that is the case, what legal implications arise ...
I was wondering if anyone was going to trip to this... Full credit, Mr. Shaw! The last time I had a fulll legal review done was back in August 1995, but at that time, any filtering of the newsgroups for content (e.g. warez, porno, etc) could be deemed to be "an application of editorial control", and shazam! you were in the "content provider" biz, and at that time, subject to all the nasty implications of the Compuserve decision (mainly that you're toast if you *ever* fail to fully exercise your editorial perview regarding responsible prevention of libelous matter, etc). Best guess at ths time, without having had a full review done, is that filtering spam at the source *might* fall into the same category. However, since in theory mail is *personal* in nature ratehr than broadcast, it might be deemed to fall into the same category as blocking all carrier route sorted bulk mail in the real world. However, note that you *can't* get USPS to do that, either. Interesting aspect to it all, that's for damn sure.... Stan -- Stanley P. Hanks Vice President, Engineering / First Point Communications (an Enron company) 210 SW Morrison St., Suite 400 / Portland OR 97204 vox (503) 464-8480 / fax (503) 464-2042 / email stan_hanks () pgn com
Current thread:
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers, (continued)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Gary E. Miller (Nov 14)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Alan Barrett (Nov 17)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Karl Denninger (Nov 17)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Joe Shaw (Nov 17)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Karl Denninger (Nov 17)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Michael Dillon (Nov 17)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Vadim Antonov (Nov 17)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Karl Denninger (Nov 17)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers david (Nov 18)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Eric M. Carroll (Nov 17)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Stan Hanks (Nov 17)
- Re: Legal Issues on Blackholeing (was AGIS signing up New Spamme Paul Flores (Nov 17)
- Message not available
- Re: Legal Issues on Blackholeing Curtis Brown (Nov 17)
- Re: Legal Issues on Blackholeing Eric Sobocinski (Nov 17)
- Re: Legal Issues on Blackholeing (was AGIS signing up New Spamme Stan Hanks (Nov 17)
- Re: Legal Issues on Blackholeing (was AGIS signing up New Spamme Henry Linneweh (Nov 17)
- Message not available
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Jay R. Ashworth (Nov 17)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Martin Hannigan (Nov 17)
- Message not available
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Kent W. England (Nov 20)
- Message not available
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers Jay R. Ashworth (Nov 21)
- Re: AGIS Signing up New Spammers J.D. Falk (Nov 21)