oss-sec mailing list archives
Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag
From: "Vincent Danen" <vdanen () redhat com>
Date: Fri, 27 Jun 2014 19:09:03 -0600
On 06/27/2014, at 14:03 PM, cve-assign () mitre org wrote:
I suppose maybe there is a CWE for not having a virus scanner, which makes sense as that could be considered an overall system weakness.Neither CVE nor CWE attempts to cover the general topic of system integration, i.e., questions such as "given the composition and role of this entire system, is it unreasonable to omit a virus scanner?" In practice, both CVE and CWE often tend to be about questions that may come up when considering somewhere around one line of code or one file of code. (This is just an observational statement, not an attempt to redefine why CVE and CWE exist.) Typical audiences may include (among others) developers who need to write a line of code safely or system administrators who need to patch a faulty line of code. This doesn't mean that there's any objection to someone taking the position that lack of a virus scanner is the most serious security concern that they see in an entire system. This is a valid perspective but is outside of the problem spaces in which CVE and CWE have been operating. Even if everyone were looking at "whether or not a flaw is a flaw" decisions in precisely the same way, a conclusion of "yes, this system would really benefit from a virus scanner" leaves open the question of the best place to capture that information.
Then shouldn't be the same be true of the HttpOnly flag? That line of thought is pretty much what I think in regards to that flag. I don't know if you missed my comment in an earlier message, so I'll note it below because I think this is the real point: "Kurt's argument about everything having an XSS makes it sound like, and the reasoning provided here as well, that we should no longer consider XSS a security flaw, but the absence of HttpOnly the security flaw. I mean, if setting this flag "fixes" all XSS issues, then we should no longer be assigning CVEs to XSS issues, only to web servers/services that do not set HttpOnly or browsers that do not respect/handle it properly. They can't _both_ get CVEs or be considered flaws, can they?" -- Vincent Danen / Red Hat Product Security
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Current thread:
- Re: Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag, (continued)
- Re: Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Murray McAllister (Jun 26)
- Re: Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Henri Salo (Jun 26)
- Re: Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Murray McAllister (Jun 26)
- Re: Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Vladimir '3APA3A' Dubrovin (Jun 26)
- Re: Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Florian Weimer (Jun 26)
- Re: Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Kurt Seifried (Jun 26)
- Re: Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Jamie Strandboge (Jun 26)
- Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag cve-assign (Jun 26)
- Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Vincent Danen (Jun 27)
- Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag cve-assign (Jun 27)
- Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Vincent Danen (Jun 27)
- Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag cve-assign (Jun 27)
- Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Vincent Danen (Jun 30)
- Re: Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Kurt Seifried (Jun 27)
- Re: Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Kurt Seifried (Jun 26)
- Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Vincent Danen (Jun 27)
- Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Kurt Seifried (Jun 27)
- Re: Question regarding CVE applicability of missing HttpOnly flag Vincent Danen (Jun 27)