nanog mailing list archives
Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR
From: Saku Ytti <saku () ytti fi>
Date: Fri, 9 Dec 2022 17:14:06 +0200
On Fri, 9 Dec 2022 at 17:07, Joshua Miller <contemno () gmail com> wrote:
I don't know that Netconf or gRPC are any faster than loading cli. Those protocols facilitate automation so that the time it takes to load any one device is not a significant factor, especially when you can roll out changes to devices in parallel. Also, it's easier to build the changes into a structured format than assemble the right syntax to interact with the CLI.
As a programmer I don't really find output format to be significant cost. If I have source of data how I emit them out doesn't matter much. I accept preferences that people have, but don't think it to be important part of solution. Adrian mentioned paramiko, and if we imagine paramiko logging into IOS-XR, and doing 'load http://...' + 'commit'. We've automated the task. Depending on your platform netconf/yang/grpc can be asset or liability, I put IOS-XR strongly in the liability part, because they don't have proper infrastructure that is datafirst, they don't have proper module for even handling configurations, but configurations are owned by individual component teams (like tunnel teams owns GRE config and so forth). Contrasting with Juniper, which is datafirst, and even CLI is 2nd class citizen taking formal data from XML RPC. In IOS-XR you will find all kind of gaps, where you can't rely on netconf/yang, which you will then spend cycles to deal with vendor. Compared to people who use the first class citizen approach, CLI format, who are already done. I did not read Steffan as though he'd be punching in anything manually, he wants to make the process itself faster, without any delays introduced by humans. And I have personally nothing to offer him, except put your server closer to the router, so you can deal with the limited TCP window sizes that hurt transfer speed. -- ++ytti
Current thread:
- Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Sander Steffann (Dec 08)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Joshua Miller (Dec 08)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Andrian Visnevschi via NANOG (Dec 09)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Saku Ytti (Dec 09)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Joshua Miller (Dec 09)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Saku Ytti (Dec 09)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Mark Tinka (Dec 12)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Andrian Visnevschi via NANOG (Dec 09)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Joshua Miller (Dec 08)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Saku Ytti (Dec 09)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Joshua Miller (Dec 09)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Saku Ytti (Dec 09)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR tim () pelican org (Dec 09)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Saku Ytti (Dec 09)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR tim () pelican org (Dec 12)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Mark Tinka (Dec 12)
- Re: Large prefix lists/sets on IOS-XR Tom Beecher (Dec 13)