nanog mailing list archives
Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections)
From: William Herrin <bill () herrin us>
Date: Wed, 2 Jun 2021 09:12:23 -0700
On Wed, Jun 2, 2021 at 5:28 AM Jared Brown <nanog-isp () mail com> wrote:
On Mon, May 31, 2021 Mike Hammett wrote:Muni broadband does suck, but that's another thread for another day.Excluding cases where muni broadband doesn't suck, why does muni broadband suck? Personally I wouldn't mind more access to dark fiber à la Stokab, much like the dry copper pairs of yesterday. If the default state of muni broadband of is suck, what is the root cause? Is it a people problem and/or can something be done to improve on the default state?
Muni broadband sucks for several reasons but the most important one is: Competition. Municipal broadband eliminates it. If it's not obvious why, feel free to Google how competition and monopolization impact product quality. It's a pretty universal trait. If you were to structure muni broadband to enhance competition rather than limit it, you might get a different result. For example, if municipalities installed and leased fiber optic cables to every structure but didn't provide any services on those cables, relying instead on third parties directly billing the customer to do so, it could work out as well as having municipalities pay for roads and letting people buy their own cars and trucks to use on them. Regards, Bill Herrin -- William Herrin bill () herrin us https://bill.herrin.us/
Current thread:
- Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) Jared Brown (Jun 02)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) Mark Tinka (Jun 02)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) William Herrin (Jun 02)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) Andy Ringsmuth (Jun 02)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) Jared Mauch (Jun 02)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) William Herrin (Jun 02)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) Harry McGregor (Jun 02)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) Mike Hammett (Jun 02)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) Christopher Morrow (Jun 02)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) Mike Hammett (Jun 02)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) John Osmon (Jun 02)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) Andy Ringsmuth (Jun 02)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) Richey Goldberg (Jun 03)
- Re: Muni broadband sucks (was: New minimum speed for US broadband connections) Mike Hammett (Jun 03)