nanog mailing list archives
Re: lists and DMARC and ARC, was Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM
From: Grant Taylor via NANOG <nanog () nanog org>
Date: Wed, 29 Nov 2017 16:00:26 -0700
On 11/29/2017 03:46 PM, Michael Thomas wrote:
You know what the original header was via the signature. You can take the delta of the current subject line and remove any additions and validate the signature. Whether you're happy with the additions is a different concern,
Are you referring to the optional z DKIM-Signature tag?Or are you referring to brute forcing what the subject was in order to derive the delta of the current subject? This would be compounded by any number of other changes to (over)singed headers / body portion.
If I were constructing a spam filter out of it, I'd give a lot of prejudice to anything added, but that's outside ofwhat you can do within the bounds of the spec.
*If* the z tag was included in the DKIM-Signature header, I can see how this would work and I agree with your distrust of said additions / alterations.
-- Grant. . . . unix || die
Attachment:
smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature
Current thread:
- Re: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM, (continued)
- Re: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM valdis . kletnieks (Dec 01)
- Re: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Owen DeLong (Dec 01)
- Re: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM bzs (Dec 01)
- Re: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Michael Thomas (Dec 01)
- Re: lists and DMARC and ARC, was Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM John Levine (Dec 01)
- Re: lists and DMARC and ARC, was Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Michael Thomas (Dec 01)
- Re: lists and DMARC and ARC, was Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM valdis . kletnieks (Dec 01)
- Re: lists and DMARC and ARC, was Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Michael Thomas (Dec 01)
- Re: lists and DMARC and ARC, was Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Grant Taylor via NANOG (Dec 01)
- Re: lists and DMARC and ARC, was Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Michael Thomas (Dec 01)
- Re: lists and DMARC and ARC, was Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Grant Taylor via NANOG (Dec 01)
- Re: lists and DMARC and ARC, was Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Michael Thomas (Dec 01)
- Re: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Eric Kuhnke (Dec 01)
- RE: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Keith Medcalf (Dec 01)
- Re: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Michael Thomas (Dec 01)
- Re: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Grant Taylor via NANOG (Dec 01)
- Re: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Michael Thomas (Dec 01)
- Re: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Grant Taylor via NANOG (Dec 01)
- Re: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM Chuck Anderson (Dec 01)
- Re: Incoming SMTP in the year 2017 and absence of DKIM John Levine (Dec 01)