nanog mailing list archives
Re: MPLS in the campus Network?
From: Javier Solis <jhazesnooty () gmail com>
Date: Fri, 21 Oct 2016 12:02:24 -0500
Our campus started off with L2 vlans spanning through the core, but we migrated to routing in the core and moved our many spanning tree/broadcast domains to the edge of buildings fronted by redundant routing with ecmp to a redundant core utilizing ospf. In a campus network the challenge becomes extending subnets across your core. You may have a college that started in one building with their own /24, but now have offices and labs in other buildings. They want to stay on the same network, but that's not feasible with the routed core setup without some other technology overlay. We end up not being able to extend the L2 like we did in the past and today we modify router ACL's to allow communications. If you already have hundreds of vlans spanned across the network, it's hard to get a campus to migrate to the routed core. I think this may be one of Marks challenge, correct me if I'm wrong please. With that said, what are the best options to be able to cost effectively scale without using vlans and maintaining a routed core? What technology would someone suggest (mpls, vxlan,etc) to be the best possible solution? Thank you to the participants in the discussion. I always enjoy reading comments posted. -Javier On Oct 21, 2016 11:46 AM, "Mark Tinka" <mark.tinka () seacom mu> wrote:
On 21/Oct/16 16:19, Marian Ďurkovič wrote:Much easier to setup, operate & maintain than MPLS and obviously much lower cost. Based on 6-months production experience, my recommendation would be to stay away from MPLS in the campus.I'd be curious to hear what MPLS-specific issues you faced in the 6 months you had to operate such a network. Been running IP/MPLS Core, Edge and Access networks for over 15 years, and apart from bugs which affect any protocol or feature implementation, I can't say it has been a nightmare to operate to the point of not recommending it. I have far fewer words to say about STP, although - I'll admit - I've never run TRILL. Mark.
Current thread:
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network?, (continued)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? Mark Tinka (Oct 20)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? Mark Tinka (Oct 20)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? Roland Dobbins (Oct 20)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? Mark Tinka (Oct 20)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? Roland Dobbins (Oct 20)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? Mark Tinka (Oct 20)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? Wayne Bouchard (Oct 24)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? Roland Dobbins (Oct 20)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? Mark Tinka (Oct 21)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? Javier Solis (Oct 21)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? Leo Bicknell (Oct 21)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? Youssef Ghorbal (Oct 21)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? James R Cutler (Oct 21)
- Re: MPLS in the campus Network? David Bass (Oct 21)