nanog mailing list archives
Re: large BCP38 compliance testing
From: Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike () swm pp se>
Date: Fri, 3 Oct 2014 21:03:45 +0200 (CEST)
On Fri, 3 Oct 2014, Rich Kulawiec wrote:
The same thing applies here: persistent, systemic sources of large-scale abuse via BCP-38 noncompliance are either: 1. Being operated by clueless, negligent, incompetent people or 2. Being operated by deliberately abusive people There are no other possibilities. (Note: "persistent, systemic". Transient, isolated problems happen to everyone and are not what I'm talking about here.) It's difficult to know which of those two are true via external observation, but it's not *necessary* to know: the appropriate remedial action remains the same in either case: stop giving them the means.
So how do we detect these and make sure they feel pain for not doing the right thing. The CIDR report hasn't incurred pain as far as I know, so public shaming doesn't seem to work even in cases where we can detect people incurring hurt on others. So how do we work this? It obviously hasn't worked so far, what do we change to make this work?
-- Mikael Abrahamsson email: swmike () swm pp se
Current thread:
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing, (continued)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Jay Ashworth (Oct 12)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Valdis . Kletnieks (Oct 02)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Roland Dobbins (Oct 02)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Jimmy Hess (Oct 05)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Octavio Alvarez (Oct 20)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Brian Rak (Oct 02)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Roland Dobbins (Oct 02)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Rich Kulawiec (Oct 02)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Mark Andrews (Oct 02)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Rich Kulawiec (Oct 03)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Mikael Abrahamsson (Oct 03)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Alain Hebert (Oct 03)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Matt Palmer (Oct 05)
- Re: large BCP38 compliance testing Andrei Robachevsky (Oct 03)