Re: RIS raw data

[Randy Bush <randy () psg com>]

> Please don't conflate the policy mechanisms enabled by the IRR policy
> *language*/specification itself with the *data* contained in the IRR

i don't.  the former is called rpsl.

> > some years back, i asked for a *simple minimal* tagging of announcements
> > to route views, just peer, customer, internal.  it got ietfed to utter
> > uselessness, with more crap welded on to it than envisioned in mad max.
>
> Wrt your last paragraph: care to share a link the I-D (or, RFC) that
> you allude to above?

http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-grow-collection-communities-08

> I think your last paragraph is alluding to tagging routes with
> standard BGP communities, based on your "simple minimal" criteria,
> before they are sent to route-views.  That strikes me as potentially
> orthogonal to issues with the present data in the IRR.

but not orthogonal to the op's direct question.

randy